• The forum upgrades are now largely complete.
    Please read this thread for more details.
    New user registrations are currently disabled.

Mags sign Dortmund player on loan

Status
Not open for further replies.

JohnnyM1 said:
To be fair you didn't specify when I'd need a foolscap pad to name the lot. For the record I think Jacob Murphy is shit.
Click to expand...
The conversation/thread is about Merino, of course Newcastle have signed poor players in the past (as have every club), based on that, I thought your comment was on this past window.

So you think Murphy is "shit", I think that it's unfair to judge him based on 71 minutes of Premier League football but in that 71 minutes he has been poor, out of our 6 new signings he would be the only one I would judge as poor, however he played well last season in the Championship scoring 8 goals and providing 8 assists, as a Sunderland fan you should be able to recognise the value in those numbers at this current time.

PhilSAFC said:
Shearer has a lot of time for Sunderland. He isn’t a childish prick who hates Sunderland. Sorry to shatter your illusions.
Click to expand...
It's just a joke Philip...
 
Last edited:
Mr Clarko said:
The conversation/thread is about Merino, of course Newcastle have signed poor players in the past (as have every club), based on that, I thought your comment was on this past window.

So you think Murphy is "shit", I think that it's unfair to judge him based on 71 minutes of Premier League football but in that 71 minutes he has been poor, out of our 6 new signings he would be the only one I would judge as poor, however he played well last season in the Championship scoring 8 goals and providing 8 assists, as a Sunderland fan you should be able to recognise the value in those numbers at this current time.


It's just a joke Philip...
Click to expand...
No he didn't actually try looking up things before you post

Tom Ince got 14 goals and 6 assists maybe you should've bought him
 
Mr Clarko said:
The conversation/thread is about Merino, of course Newcastle have signed poor players in the past (as have every club), based on that, I thought your comment was on this past window.

So you think Murphy is "shit", I think that it's unfair to judge him based on 71 minutes of Premier League football but in that 71 minutes he has been poor, out of our 6 new signings he would be the only one I would judge as poor, however he played well last season in the Championship scoring 8 goals and providing 8 assists, as a Sunderland fan you should be able to recognise the value in those numbers at this current time.


It's just a joke Philip...
Click to expand...

Not bad. Not quite at McGeady's level last season but not bad all the same.
 
Bear said:
No he didn't actually try looking up things before you post

Tom Ince got 14 goals and 6 assists maybe you should've bought him
Click to expand...
Jacob Murphy, Championship 16/17, 37 appearances, 8 goals, 8 assists, 2621 minutes played via transfermarkt.

rentaghost said:
Not bad. Not quite at McGeady's level last season but not bad all the same.
Click to expand...
Murphy (22) had a goal contribution (goal and assist) every 163.9 minutes in the Championship 16/17

McGeady (31) had a goal contribution (goal and assist) every 164.1 minutes in the Championship 16/17
 
Last edited:
Mr Clarko said:
Jacob Murphy, Championship 16/17, 37 appearances, 8 goals, 8 assists, 2621 minutes played via transfermarkt.


Murphy (22) had a goal contribution (goal and assist) every 163.9 minutes in the Championship 16/17

McGeady (31) had a goal contribution (goal and assist) every 164.1 minutes in the Championship 16/17
Click to expand...
Crazy looking at those stats knowing McGeady only cost 250k . utter lunacy the transfer WINDOW in recent yearses .
 
Ashley In!! said:
Bit soon to judge his performances for you then. We however can confirm he isn't up to much in the premier league. Obviously having never seen him at that level you'll know best though. :lol:
Click to expand...
I have seen him play in the Premier League, I have seen him play for Newcastle over the course of a whole season and yes I do know best.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top