• The forums will be unavailable for a few hours on Saturday 6th June, when they do return they will initially be in a degraded state with some features missing, but normal posting/reading will be possible. The main website will not be affected by these updates.
    New user registrations are currently disabled.

Not drawing the Mags in the cup

Status
Not open for further replies.
Correct.

Kirchoff ran the show against you lot, and you now have less talented players. He'd instantly be your best midfielder. Kone would instantly be your best centre half too.

I didnt argue on Kirchoff, so not sure what your point is sir?
Kone has been gash since you refused to sell to Everton.
 

Correct.

Kirchoff ran the show against you lot, and you now have less talented players. He'd instantly be your best midfielder. Kone would instantly be your best centre half too.

Come on now, one game doesn't define a player's ability. And while he's good, and pivotal to your survival hopes in my opinion, Kirchoff fundamentally would not be our best midfielder. Ritchie is certainly better, and arguments could be made for Shelvey too, on current form.

Don't know about Kone, he's looked suspect in a quite a few games, but I'd have to see him more often and not just make judgements based on the occasions I've seen you on tv (highlights or otherwise).

It's a bit daft to think all players in the Premier League are better than all players in the Championship by virtue of being in a higher league. Especially as it's simply because you've a bias against your local rivals. Your support of sunderland shouldn't be defined by your criticism of Newcastle.
 
Come on now, one game doesn't define a player's ability. And while he's good, and pivotal to your survival hopes in my opinion, Kirchoff fundamentally would not be our best midfielder. Ritchie is certainly better, and arguments could be made for Shelvey too, on current form.

Don't know about Kone, he's looked suspect in a quite a few games, but I'd have to see him more often and not just make judgements based on the occasions I've seen you on tv (highlights or otherwise).

It's a bit daft to think all players in the Premier League are better than all players in the Championship by virtue of being in a higher league. Especially as it's simply because you've a bias against your local rivals. Your support of sunderland shouldn't be defined by your criticism of Newcastle.

Ritchie better? Haway man.

Shelvey on current form? He is up against much inferior players man, that's why his form has changed from last season. Put him in league one and you'll think he is the best in the world.

It's nothing to do with bias. You went down for a reason, you weren't good enough. And your best players are those who took you down/couldnt cut it in the top flight.
 
The list of players HugeBlurt has just listed man.... even put Colback in there ahead of Ndong, Cattermole and Kirchoff, what a tit. He is so transparent, the gonk :lol:

Seems your reading level is the same as your posting level:rolleyes:

Colback would have moonwalked into that starting 11 on saturday and the others even if we had a fully fit squad would walk straight in and improve our team massively.

If they were from bournemouth nobody would argue but since they are from newcastle ooooooh lets just pretend they wouldnt and say they are shit its small time as fuck and embarrassing.

I would swap squads with them in a heartbeat and im sure a lot of others without any agenda would aswell.
 
Ritchie better? Haway man.

Shelvey on current form? He is up against much inferior players man, that's why his form has changed from last season. Put him in league one and you'll think he is the best in the world.
Well, I can't pick holes in that exhaustive counter-argument. :lol:
 
Ritchie better? Haway man.

Shelvey on current form? He is up against much inferior players man, that's why his form has changed from last season. Put him in league one and you'll think he is the best in the world.
f***ing hell man give it up:lol:
 
People worried about playing the Mags in a round of a cup draw that wasn't actually made?! :lol::lol:

f***ing hell man. Pitiful this place at times.

I'd love to play them in a cup competition anytime.
 
People worried about playing the Mags in a round of a cup draw that wasn't actually made?! :lol::lol:

f***ing hell man. Pitiful this place at times.

I'd love to play them in a cup competition anytime.

Nah mate, the likes of Colback would now suddenly walk into our best team, apparently :lol: (look at the list of players Hugeblurt named ffs).
 
Any comment on the Shelvey bit, or just accepting you've been blarn out?
You can only beat the teams in front of you, but Shelvey's problem has never been a lack of ability, it was a lack of application and focus. Benitez seems to have addressed that. Kirchoff is a better player than the position his team is in, as is Shelvey. And Ritchie. And Perez. and so on and so forth.

Ritchie has done it in the Premier League and is now doing it in the Championship, your argument against him being a better midfielder than Kirchoff was, and I quote, "Haway man.". If anyone has been "blarn out", I'm afraid it's yourself.
 
Are you for real?

Defoe and kone are the only 2 outfield players that would get in their team yet they have at least 6 or 7 that would walk into ours.

Perez
Ritchie
Gayle
Shelvey
Colback
Diame
Yedlin

All would walk into our current starting 11 and most with our fully fit 11.

Just blinkered bollocks playing the uber as per.

:lol:

My word.
 
Any comment on the Shelvey bit, or just accepting you've been blarn out?



So you don't think Shelvey looking good this season compared to last is due to him now being up against lesser players? Hugeblurt strikes again :lol:
You take jan and catts and i will stick with what anyone with out rose tinted glasses would do and take shelvey and ritchie.

Anybody without an agenda would see that ritchie and perez would be better than anything we have on the wings and shelvey would run our midfield like i said if they were from another team you wouldnt argue but as its the mags you are too narrow minded to accept it.
 
You can only beat the teams in front of you, but Shelvey's problem has never been a lack of ability, it was a lack of application and focus. Benitez seems to have addressed that. Kirchoff is a better player than the position his team is in, as is Shelvey. And Ritchie. And Perez. and so on and so forth.

Ritchie has done it in the Premier League and is now doing it in the Championship, your argument against him being a better midfielder than Kirchoff was, and I quote, "Haway man.". If anyone has been "blarn out", I'm afraid it's yourself.

You're right mate, Shelvey has always been class, just coincidence he looked shit last season, in the premier league. Silly me.
 
You take jan and catts and i will stick with what anyone with out rose tinted glasses would do and take shelvey and ritchie.

Anybody without an agenda would see that ritchie and perez would be better than anything we have on the wings and shelvey would run our midfield like i said if they were from another team you wouldnt argue but as its the mags you are too narrow minded to accept it.

Why couldn't Shelvey run the mags midfield last season?

Why did we boss the midfield last time we played them?

I'm amazed they couldn't beat us, villa and Norwich. Come to think of it, it's astounding they went down.
 
You're right mate, Shelvey has always been class, just coincidence he looked shit last season, in the premier league. Silly me.
Worse than ndong?

Worse than 50 minutes jan?

Worse than rodwell?

Worse than mcnair?

Worse than pienaar?

Worse than catts?

You are clueless and clearly happy having a midfield void of any creativity and littered with dross.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top