Is this the first time we have ever......

[Stevos]

…..had 5 Premiership winners in our squad?

Pantilimon
O’Shea
Brown
Rodwell
Johnson

 

[naughtynose]

Aye

 

[AssensMackem]

Was that a question?

Aye

End of thread I reckon

 

[not spavin]

No, there was that time when... on second thoughts, aye.

 

[johnnyat87]

What about:
O'Shea
Brown
Richardson
Johnson
Saha

 

[chriswallace85]

Rodwell hasn't won it.

 

[JonnyJarman]

Jiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii

 

[johnnyat87]

Rodwell hasn't won it.

So on that basis, no it's not the first time, because it's happened before and because we don't currently have it. Great thread

 

[Stevos]

Rodwell hasn't won it.

?????

Was that a question?


End of thread I reckon

I enjoyed it while it lasted.

 

[magic snood]

Rodwell hasn't won it.

got a medal iirc there mate

 

[chriswallace85]

?????

You need a minimum of ten appearances to get a medal. He didn't make the cut. Whether or not City give him one anyway I dunno.

 

[Cockney Mackem]

Rodwell hasn't won it.

Apparently his one start and four sub appearances were enough under updated rules to gain him a medal.

According to this link - which also suggests he looks like the soppy wolf boy from Twilight when he grows his hair a bit.

You must be logged on to see external links

It's the Mail, so the whole story could be made up to show a black man getting an undeserved handout

 

[AssensMackem]

What about:
O'Shea
Brown
Richardson
Johnson
Saha

Richadson and Johnson/Saha were not here at the same time.

 

[chriswallace85]

got a medal iirc there mate

So he did...

You must be logged on to see external links

I reckon it doesn't count.

 

[johnnyat87]

Richadson and Johnson/Saha were not here at the same time.

All played at least once according to this

You must be logged on to see external links

EDIT: Apart from Brown.... but he was definitely here

 

[the streaker]

You need a minimum of ten appearances to get a medal. He didn't make the cut. Whether or not City give him one anyway I dunno.

No it was cut to 5 and he started one and made four subs appearances...........and now they give you 40 medals and its up to you how you hand them out anyway..

At 109 minutes mind I bet that's close to a record......

 

[AssensMackem]

All played at least once according to this

You must be logged on to see external links

The wiki page says the same. Richardson left when Johnson/Saha came in.

Edit: ok, I see - one week overlap

 

[chriswallace85]

Apparently his one start and four sub appearances were enough under updated rules to gain him a medal.

According to this link - which also suggests he looks like the soppy wolf boy from Twilight when he grows his hair a bit.

You must be logged on to see external links

It's the Mail, so the whole story could be made up to show a black man getting an undeserved handout

Aye. There's a pic of him wearing his medal on google like.

Fergie's comment about Buttner's fair enough like, so if Rodwell's showed similar application then fair enough.

 

[johnnyat87]

The wiki page says the same. Richardson left when Johnson/Saha came in

Saha and Johnson came on 16th and 24th August. Richardson left on 31st..... therefore........

The wiki page says the same. Richardson left when Johnson/Saha came in.

Edit: ok, I see - one week overlap

So they were all in the squad at the same time
So the answer to the OP is No

 

[MrMojo]

It's a meaningless claim to fame. A bit like expecting people to be impressed cos we had Dwight Yorke and Andy Cole playing up front for us.