Judging by talent only who is the best and worst player we've had since promotion?

[mackemdr]

I.e. since 2006 in the Prem. Not taking into consideration injuries, attitudes etc.

On raw talent- perhaps Gyan as best.

Worst- Roy o'Donovan

 

[blackcat1395]

Sessegnon. End of thread.

 

[mackemdr]

Sessegnon. End of thread.

well thats half an answer.

Congrats on failing the reading exam

 

[Dazza619]

Pure talent- Malbranque

No talent- Mcshane (god knows how that fucker keeps getting into Premier League defences)

 

[SAFC Wilks]

Best - Mignolet, Steed & Brown (when he's played)
Worst - Stokes, Mcshane, Gardner

 

[Hatful Of Hollow]

Best - Mignolet, Steed & Brown (when he's played)
Worst - Stokes, Mcshane, Gardner

Gardner is shit but we've definitely had worse

 

[SAFC Wilks]

Gardner is shit but we've definitely had worse

Ignore me, still seething from his performance v Chelsea, so it's not the most neutral view

 

[Vindaloo Man]

Best: Steed or Sess.
Worst: Anderson, Halford, McShane - the list is endless tbh.

 

[nordic]

Best - Mignolet, Steed & Brown (when he's played)
Worst - Stokes, Mcshane, Gardner

I'm not a big fan of Gardner but even so that's very harsh no way is he one of the worst three players we have had since promotion.

What about Angeleri, McShane, Healy as the worst and
Mig, Brown and Steed as the best.[DOUBLEPOST=1387452766][/DOUBLEPOST]

I'm not a big fan of Gardner but even so that's very harsh no way is he one of the worst three players we have had since promotion.

What about Angeleri, McShane, Healy as the worst and
Mig, Brown and Steed as the best.

Best: Steed or Sess.
Worst: Anderson, Halford, McShane - the list is endless tbh.

Forgot about Anderson and Halford Man we've had some crap.

 

[Scootsie]

Steed, Sess, Gyan, Zenden, Brown, Mensah. All naturally brilliant imo.

Worst is probably O'donovan like aye.

 

[SAFC Wilks]

I'm not a big fan of Gardner but even so that's very harsh no way is he one of the worst three players we have had since promotion.

What about Angeleri, McShane, Healy as the worst and
Mig, Brown and Steed as the best.[DOUBLEPOST=1387452766][/DOUBLEPOST]

Forgot about Anderson and Halford Man we've had some crap.

Only wanted to put in one of our current crop in there, was between him and Ji
They can go in as well though, I forgot about them
Cheers for reminding me...

 

[Jack Blue]

Best: Mignolet and Malbranque

Worst: Gardner

Sorry but Gardner has played a million times more than the likes of O'Donovan so I've factored that in. He is worse than Jeff Whitley with a decent strike.

 

[Y2Jonny]

Best: Steed, Gyan, Sess
Worst: Anderson, McShane, O'Donovan, the Greek lad (Kyriakos or however you spell it)

 

[HutchSafc]

Sess

Prica

Edit - Odonovan as well for worst. Forgot about him.

 

[urmom777]

Best: Mignolet
Worst: Prica

TBH says alot when it's really difficult to nname the worst as there's so many to chose from.

 

[Andy Reids Love Chil]

Best - Sessegnon or Malbranque

Worst - Halford

 

[nordic]

I've just remembered we had McCartney back and he was terrible........Ian Harte

 

[Weasel501]

Best - Steed, Bent, Gyan, Sess
Worst - Murphy,Whitehead, Riveros, Cabral, Wickham

 

[nordic]

Best: Mignolet
Worst: Prica

TBH says alot when it's really difficult to nname the worst as there's so many to chose from.

Yep best player 4 possibly 5 candidates worst player possible candidates literally hundreds to choose from.

 

[Randy Ostrich]

I've just remembered we had McCartney back and he was terrible........Ian Harte

Aye, McCartney was bloody awful.

No-one opted for Danny Graham yet?