Yann M'Vila


Status
Not open for further replies.

ShieldsGreggs4

Central Defender
In my opinion he has took his foot off the gas second half of the season and his performances have been average and occasionally poor. Wonder why?
 
In my opinion he has took his foot off the gas second half of the season and his performances have been average and occasionally poor. Wonder why?


There has been a lot of talk about this in recent weeks and up until today I thought it was a bit overplayed, he was really poor today though. I think early in the season he was expected to do everything defensively and going forward. I think since Kirchoff has come into the side he is just doing a simpler, more restricted job. I thought he played well at Newcastle for example. Today though he had a stinker.
 
Strange. There's no doubt he's a quality footballer. Maybe it's a good thing he's off form - might make other clubs less keen to sign him at the end of the season. Could do with him staying.
 
He has influenced fuck all for months TBH. Right off the ball. Need to see really. Was the worst of our midfield today.

Load of shit this post like, his influence has been lesser in recent months but he is an intelligent passer and starts off many of our attacks by not panicking on the ball and moving the ball on well. He had a below average game today but he is still a very important side

The bloke most likely needs a rest, barely played for Rubin /Inter then didn't have much of a pre-season. He was head an shoulders above anyone else the first half of the season then his form drops and people are straight on his back, poor that in my opinion
 
He didn't mate

See this post below and try to say that again but this time explain in maybe a sentence or two as to why you think that way?

http://www.readytogo.net/smb/threads/cattermole.1216721/page-8#post-22642843

Also who should have been on instead of him given the options we had today? If you say Rodwell then again look at the comparison of Cattermole's contributions today and Rodwell in his last 2 games.

The simple fact is we are missing the player for that position but to ignore that Cattermole played decent overall stinks of an agenda against the player. At least when I slag Rodwell off I show why I feel he contributes very little for the role he's supposed to be playing in. If Rodwell had done what Cattermole had done today then I'd have given him at least a 7 and put him 2nd place for MOTM behind Kirchhoff.
 
There has been a lot of talk about this in recent weeks and up until today I thought it was a bit overplayed, he was really poor today though. I think early in the season he was expected to do everything defensively and going forward. I think since Kirchoff has come into the side he is just doing a simpler, more restricted job. I thought he played well at Newcastle for example. Today though he had a stinker.
You make a good point. Kirchhoff is a class act, yet Mvilla and Catts in particular dont seem to gel with him. We seem to have found the top drawer midfielder we have craved and at the same time, made our next best two..:poorer.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Back
Top