Would You Swap......


Status
Not open for further replies.
F

festa

Guest
Gordon for Jonny Evans and Wellbeck?

Don't think I would.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Assuming Evans doesn't have any long-term injury problems (I don't know if he's nackered or not but seems to have been out a lot over the last year) then all day long.
 
No.

If Mensah can stay fit he's twice the player Evans is.

I like Welbeck but Campbell will be fit and with Gyan and Bent around I'd rather have Gordon ........ total class at Spurs despite it being his first game back in ages.
 
no but man u would never consider that anyway unless we gave them an extra 5 or so mill
 
Nope, Evans seems to have gone backwards and while Welbeck was great on Sunday he is still very inconsistent. Gordon though is one of the most solid and consistent goalkeepers around.
 
No.

If Mensah can stay fit he's twice the player Evans is.

I like Welbeck but Campbell will be fit and with Gyan and Bent around I'd rather have Gordon ........ total class at Spurs despite it being his first game back in ages.

Can Barton and Carroll stay out of court?
 
No.

Agree that Evans appears to have gone backwards although that may be due in part to not playing regularly. Wouldn't swap him for Bramble given what he's done since signing.

We all know about Mensah's ability but with him its always going to be about fitness.

Welbeck was iffy before Stoke game, had two good games (Stoke and Spurs) and one excellent game (Chelsea), but jury is still out.

Keep what we've got for me like
 
Evans hasn't improved from what I've seen, so no.

However, I think Welbeck is going to be a top player, and I really hope we get him permanently.
 
not a chance, gordon is one of the top keepers in the league. agree with winnie as well, evans had great potential but he needs first team football. not gettin that when rio nd vidic are there
 
No because we're in more need of a top quality keeper than Evans or Welbeck.

I'd still take Evans though - being average at Man Utd and everything being highlighted when you're playing for trophies and in the CL doesn't mean he's gone backwards, it's just a slightly different level and different expectations.

We need to sort Gordon's contract out soon though, I'm amazed we haven't heard it being mentioned.
 
Not a chance.

That's says a lot about how good Henderson is/might become, consider how disappointed we all were not to be able to sign Evans permanently.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Back
Top