Worst 3 Sunderland Players I have ever seen


Status
Not open for further replies.
I had Howey in my top 3, Aiston was rubbish but didn't really see much of him he only played a handful of games that i can remember, same for Angell didn't play enough games to make a judgement. Hall was rubbish too, in all fairness there are several players that could be included from that era.

Nowhere near as many that could have been in there from 7/8 yrs earlier

I'll raise you a Swindlehurst or a European Cup winning Kennedy - or perhaps a Buchanon

Or Hetztke - aye its Hetzke - but then again David Corner ????

And if you are older than that -- try Mark Lynch for utter, utter garbage

And from today's lot - although we are playing at a far higher level, Abdul Morehamheady is right up with the best of them - wouldn't get in my Sunday league team the morning after the team Xmas do
 
I would say

No 3 Milton Nunez
No 2 Seamus McDonagh

No 1 ELMO

What do others think?
The list is endless. Agree with McDonagh, a total nightmare in goal, the other two could come from the likes of Kevin Kyle, Gary Breen Jeff Whitely, Phill Babb, Jason McAteer, Gavin McCann, Kelvin Davis, The Invisible Man Tommy Miller. etc, etc. The List could take allnight.
 
I know you read some stupid opinions on this board but it is only when you read 90% of the replies on this thread that you realise most do not have any football knowledge at all :-(
 
Rade Prica
Kevin Kyle
Thomas Hauser
Ian Sampson
Tim Carter
Ingham
Jeff Whitley
Robbie Elliot
Clive Clarke
Paul Stewart

Sorry more than 3 and I could go on....

Most overated:
Keiran Richardson
Michael Turner
Danny Collins
 
If Paul McShane had played for us in the championship he wouldn't get half the stick on here that he does. He was playing one league higher than his ability and got found out. Decent championship player imo. In my 37 years i have seen worse.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fGMuoxihmu4

This is a compilation of his mistakes when he played regularly from August - December in 07/08. The bloke who made it probably could have added another 5 minutes if he included the Mags horror show in April.
 
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fGMuoxihmu4

This is a compilation of his mistakes when he played regularly from August - December in 07/08. The bloke who made it probably could have added another 5 minutes if he included the Mags horror show in April.

Did he have sponsorship on the souls of his shoes.....horrific. The new arsehole he got ripped by owen at the mags was one of the most embrassing things I've seen on a football pitch

To class elmo in with this latest vintage clown or even the Nos (ask a blades fan what they think of him) is absurd
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Back
Top