Simon Mignolet


Status
Not open for further replies.
Because I saw some on here saying "He's the best keeper in the PL" and that he should have been in the team of the season.

There's a few that still thing he kept us up on his own. As if he went out onto the pitch by himself and just saved a barrage of shots for 90 mins.

The lad is decent but nothing special, basically my point.

There were very few better than him in the league in 2012/13 to be fair and would have him back here in a heartbeat.
 
I would say maybe 3rd best keeper in the league that season.

Red and white goggles off like.

Think De Gea was better than him that year, but can't really think of anybody else who was as good as Mignolet.

Thought he was an excellent keeper for us, but at the same time I wouldn't be surprised if there is some truth in the rumours about Rodgers not being at all convinced by him.
 
Think De Gea was better than him that year, but can't really think of anybody else who was as good as Mignolet.

Thought he was an excellent keeper for us, but at the same time I wouldn't be surprised if there is some truth in the rumours about Rodgers not being at all convinced by him.

I'd maybe say Lloris too.

Yeah same. Think we got a good deal all in all.
 
Gordon was a better keeper before his injury problems like. Mig was massively overrated here

He's looking far from convincing for Liverpool atm. That 3rd goal tonight was embarrassing
 
Fine keeper but had a poor game tonight.....think he should have saved the first ....had an absolute mare for the 3rd - allowed Aguero to slip the ball in at the near post, a Sunday morning keeper error that
 
I don't think we're missing him considering how well mannone has been, granted he's got his faults too, but he seems to be and shown hes a more than able replacement. Just hope he signs a new deal as soon as possible
 


I remember getting pelters on here. It was the night before Villa away two seasons back.

A lot of posters were saying "Mignolet should be in team of the season, easily the best keeper". We shipped 6 goals, he had an absolute mare.

I appreciate he had a lot of good games as well mind, but he actually cost us quite a few goals I thought.
 
I remember getting pelters on here. It was the night before Villa away two seasons back.

A lot of posters were saying "Mignolet should be in team of the season, easily the best keeper". We shipped 6 goals, he had an absolute mare.

I appreciate he had a lot of good games as well mind, but he actually cost us quite a few goals I thought.
Nowt special mate.. We have just as good in Vito and Pants who i think is a great keeper.

We stole money from the scousers for both Mig and Henderson imo.
 
Said it before and I will again, average goalkeeper.

Massively overrated when he was here. £9m was a cracking deal.

*Puts tin hat on*

Larger skillset needed at teams close to the top of the table, but he proved he was very good at what he was able to demonstrate here.

Liverpool paid a fee for the loss he was too us rather than what his performances proved he would give them: they did the same with James years ago.

Will we sign another 4 keepers at 2 million a pop before other clubs at the top of the division are impressed enough to slap a big wedge on the table? I think so (but hope not) so I'm not so sure we got such a great deal out of it.
 
Can't believe people are saying Mannone is better :lol:

Ok so he should have moved his feet quicker for the 3rd but Christ the balls got to go along way before it gets to the goal. Mannone gets wrong footed from 20 yards +.

The way Liverpool play they leave themselves open and having a keeper like Mignolet who is brilliant off his line and is a brilliant shot stopper is a massive bonus to them. He's not all round brilliant but he's good enough for them easily.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Back
Top