Sharpshooter
Midfield
Scholes easily. Most complete footballer of the three.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
He scored 2 goals in the whole tournament ffs. Hardly dragged you to winning it.
Lampard scored more in that seasons competition but his team mates let him down.
There is no way, no way Scholes or Lampard could have dragged an average Liverpool team to a CL win, carried that team for years.
Whereas I can easily see Gerrard smashing in goals at Chelsea with Makelele behind him, and I can see Gerrard winning title after title at United.
All superb players, think it just comes down to personal preference really and mine is Paul Scholes.
All 3 are a big miss to their clubs and football in general. Now we've all got to put up with expensive, overated shite like Pogba who couldn't clean the boots of these lads.
Funny Scholes never won a PFA Player of the Year award then! Neither did Lampard so, as he was the only one of the three to win it, then Gerrard must have been the better player.Scholes is the choice of those who know about football. He is also the choice of people like Messi, Xavi, Ronaldo and Zidane (who called him the only great English midfielder).
Load of rubbish tbh. Gerrard was class before Alonso turned up at Liverpool but of course he and Liverpool were better with a brilliant player like Alonso in the team.That Liverpool team without Alonso are nothing. As soon as Alonso left Gerrard's form suffered.
Also Gerrard was a selfish player. Are Giggs and Beckham as effective with Gerrard I don't think so.
Gerrard was obviously top class but he was a typical British midfielder just pure power he wasn't a very intelligent footballer.
People look at Scholes stats and think he's overrated. How many times did he lay on goals via Beckham and Giggs though?
Gerrard looked shit for England and that's because he didn't have an Alonso to make him look good.
All superb players, think it just comes down to personal preference really and mine is Paul Scholes.
All 3 are a big miss to their clubs and football in general. Now we've all got to put up with expensive, overated shite like Pogba who couldn't clean the boots of these lads.
Load of rubbish tbh. Gerrard was class before Alonso turned up at Liverpool but of course he and Liverpool were better with a brilliant player like Alonso in the team.
How was Scholes for England? Imo it was terrible management by our managers especially Sven to not be able to find a system that got the best out of Scholes and Gerrard.
Funny Scholes never won a PFA Player of the Year award then! Neither did Lampard so, as he was the only one of the three to win it, then Gerrard must have been the better player.
Or are you going to try and say that footballers know nothing about football?
Gerrard was much more complete. He played RB, centre mid, right mid and no.10 and did it all at a high level. The other two could play in one position
Yes and it hardly helps your cause does it?!Did you Ginola won the PFA player of the year in Man Utds treble season![]()