Ross on the Red


Status
Not open for further replies.
they only overturn obvious errors. even if you argue it's harsh(it wasn't imo. clear red) there's not a chance it'll get overturned

Exactly. You could argue red or not until you're blue in the face but it's certainly not a 'clear and obvious error'.
 
Deluded.

Straight red all day long.

Will get an extra game added for a frivolous appeal added now.


No, he got sent off because it was a shit tackle.

He is the other side of it from the camera and ref, you can't actually see whether he even leads in with his right studs or not from the view we have on the shitty stream.

No chance it will get overturned like
 
I think if you listen to the interview Ross is pretty clear that he doesn't normally comment on Ref's performances and certainly didn't with previous red's.


I think you're correct.
We have had some shocking refs this season (mostly trying to prove they arent intimidated by the big club in the league) and JR has kept his counsel and hasnt been critical However, if JR is having a go at the ref I think it tells me the ref was shocking today.

I think its a stupid tackle but harsh for a red. He made it way too easy for a poor referee though.
 
We have had some shocking refs this season (mostly trying to prove they arent intimidated by the big club in the league) and JR has kept his counsel and hasnt been critical However, if JR is having a go at the ref I think it tells me the ref was shocking today.

I think its a stupid tackle but harsh for a red. He made it way too easy for a poor referee though.
Its a bit like Ref's looking to book Cattermole - he gets booked for challenges no one else does. Power needs to learn from Cattermole and avoid that sort of challenge.
 
Deluded.

Straight red all day long.

Will get an extra game added for a frivolous appeal added now.


No, he got sent off because it was a shit tackle.
We only got a frivolous appeal because we appealed the length of the ban and not the decision. This isn't a frivolous appeal. It won't be overturned though.
 
I agree with him tbh.

Studs up? Nope
Late? Yes - but no later than numerous other challenges in the game. The foul on James as he cleared the ball im first half (warning). The foul on flannigan in six yard box by their centre forward that left him polaxed. (warning). I’m sure there were tens of others both ways that were just as late.
Reckless? Nope - Less so than the two I’ve mentioned above.
Dangerous? Obviously not.

To uphold the red card they’ll need to pin it on a rule - there isn’t one. Having a shit first touch is not a red card
 
Its a bit like Ref's looking to book Cattermole - he gets booked for challenges no one else does. Power needs to learn from Cattermole and avoid that sort of challenge.

He doesn't. It's a myth, but if people say something over and over again, you might just start to believe it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Back
Top