No it won't.
Phillips wants it....
- Thread starter rubberface
- Start date
skullmeister
Striker
The main argument against is that he has zero managerial experience - absolute madness to even interview him for the job.
As You Were
Midfield
He comes across as being too nice to me to be a manager
Horace Cope
Winger
Zero expectations of Bowyer. Charlton was in a financial crisis up for sale all sorts of issues. Fleetwood there was no pressure either. We are a different kettle of fish. Teams around us know we need promotion they smell blood
Why though? My point is how much did experience did the likes of Keane have?
How much experience does someone like Ainsworth or others in the frame have at managing a club this size?? Ross said he was taken a back with the actual size of the club when he got to understand it.
Again, Bowyer or a Barton how much "experience" did they have before their relative success down here??
Stortford
Winger
The club and supporters need a lift which SKP would provide massively.
We got that when Keane came in and he had no managerial experience but gave the players and crowd self belief, confidence is massive in football.
The shortlist seems rather uninspiring and given that I don’t think the Dell boys are coming to play then we need someone to lift the club, SKP for me.
houghton cut head
Striker
Did nee harm for Bob Paisley
If only!I agree, that was my point in posting it. Seems one of the main arguments against.
I wonder how some would feel if SKP got a job like Wycombe or Fleetwood and they were above in the league?
tunstallhill
Striker
He hasn't got the right character unfortunately for him. Too nice of a lad. Not a thinker though, in my opinion. Posted on another thread about when I met him at a talk in. Not management material in my opinion. Hes just a lad
Anthly
Central Defender
Moyes, Grayson and Coleman had loads of experience and were utter garbage. Lampard and Gerrard has zero experience and have done well.Give Super Kev a chance.
Fair play, though I'd imagine he'd have a different persona at a fan's talk-in as opposed to in the dressing room or on the training pitch?
skullmeister
Striker
For me it's too big a gamble, even if he had managed a short period in a lower league to cut his teeth, learn from mistakes made etc.
He is a legend but I'm just not convinced he is managerial material. If he had some of this on his CV then great but he hasn't.
All opinions like but I would be very worried if he came in, yes the crowd would be buzzing but that would change if we don't win.
A club nearby appointed a legend with no managerial experience and it didn't end well.
Absolutely! That's my concern with getting a manager from a Wycombe or even Wigan!! St Mirren to SAFC proved too much for Jack Ross
Shearer's a wanker tho
Even PDC done what that clown couldn't and he smashed the c**ts in their own back yard in the process! For every Shearer, there is a Keane, Lampard of Gerrard. Point being we'll never know unless Phillips is given a chance somewhere.
Last edited:
Anthly
Central Defender
Can’t believe all these anti Super Kev for manager posts. When SK signed as a player there weren’t great any expectations ,and he turned into SAFC legend.Absolutely! That's my concern with getting a manager from a Wycombe or even Wigan!! St Mirren to SAFC proved too much for Jack Ross
Shearer's a wanker tho
For every Shearer, there is a Keane, Lampard of Gerrard. Point being we'll never know unless Phillips is given a chance somewhere.
Stop all the negative “ he’s got no experience “ crap and give the guy a chance. He’s a must for me.
Same folk will probably moan like fuck when we get a experienced league one manager in
Ainsworth incoming anyway by the looks of it!
Last edited:
A club nearby appointed a legend with no managerial experience and it didn't end well.
[/QUOTE]
Whilst I agree with not wanting skp (don't really know why though)....that club nearby also appointed another legend with no managerial experience in the 90s and that turned out pretty well for them
. Every appointment is a gamble....after all those years at Everton who would have expected moyes to be so shit. I guess we were all hopimg for the takeover to be announced so that we could be looking at managers to move with us to (hopefully) at least the upper and of the championship. With the names being bandied around it appears we are again appointing on the cheap just to get us out the league. I expect to be totally underwhelmed but still think we needed a change and hope the next person surprises us all .
[/QUOTE]
Whilst I agree with not wanting skp (don't really know why though)....that club nearby also appointed another legend with no managerial experience in the 90s and that turned out pretty well for them
. Every appointment is a gamble....after all those years at Everton who would have expected moyes to be so shit. I guess we were all hopimg for the takeover to be announced so that we could be looking at managers to move with us to (hopefully) at least the upper and of the championship. With the names being bandied around it appears we are again appointing on the cheap just to get us out the league. I expect to be totally underwhelmed but still think we needed a change and hope the next person surprises us all .
Anthly
Central Defender
Realistically SKP is the only man for the job. Don’t want to hear nonsense about him not having any experience. Lampard and Gerrard had no experience. He could make himself into an even bigger legend. These anti Phillips posts really annoy me . What have they got against the guy? Also I have £20 at 20/1 at SKP being next SAFC manager!!!
allmagsaretossas
Winger
Out of all the names mentioned ad rather take a chance on skp than any of them all day every day
doodlebugs
Winger
ah,you mean a Grayson type of manager,tis a geet big no from me,lets try something different for a change,Moyes,Grayson,Coleman,then the jock,there's got to be a decent choice out there
