DPTT
Winger
Ability alone does not make him or anyone else a top player. The fact you say his attitude needs to change even though he is 25 pretty much guarantees he will never be a top player.That all depends on how you want to view it.
If you want to decide whether a top player becomes not a top player depending on whether the club he's at is having issues and his attitude and form aren't right then that's up to you.
To me, he is a top player regardless.
The same goes for Maxi.
His ability makes him a top player.
His attitude needs to change but he is a top player, to me.