Neuer should be off


Status
Not open for further replies.
So they can't jump when an attacker is anywhere near them? Neuer got the ball first so he didn't barge through him and surely any ball into the box from a set piece is too dangerous to go for as well?
His knee was in his f***ing face man!
 
No i think they should jump when it doesnt result in killing people along the way, he didnt have a right to go for that legally


Your argument its the other players fault for not getting out of the way of the foul

Its a world cup final, its a passionate game, its a contact sport where there are injuries / dangerous challenges every week. He had every right to take the ball and man
 
I'm not gona repeat myself..
The keepers jump with there knees up on crosses to protect themselves and to give a bit of distance between people u cant jump into someone with your knee that high to compete for the ball its dangerous play and a red card regardless if he got the ball

But that is going to happen anytime a keeper goes for the ball from a set piece and attackers get out of the way or jump to compete. Higuain didn't compete for the ball, that's why his knee was in his face.
He was trying to shield it he was in more control of the situation than the keeper!
 
The keepers jump with there knees up on crosses to protect themselves and to give a bit of distance between people u cant jump into someone with your knee that high to compete for the ball its dangerous play and a red card regardless if he got the ball


He was trying to shield it he was in more control of the situation than the keeper!

He didn't have the ball at any point so he wasn't in control. Regardless of what he was trying to do, he didn't shield it because the keeper got there first BEFORE he made contact with the player.
 
The keepers jump with there knees up on crosses to protect themselves and to give a bit of distance between people u cant jump into someone with your knee that high to compete for the ball its dangerous play and a red card regardless if he got the ball


He was trying to shield it he was in more control of the situation than the keeper!

Well he did, and won the ball and now he's just won the world cup. Sure he's gutted
 
I've not read the thread

It wasn't a foul. He got to the ball first, and was in complete control of his movement.

he's a great goalkeeper, and it was an excellent display of his talent. simple as that.
 
I've not read the thread

It wasn't a foul. He got to the ball first, and was in complete control of his movement.

he's a great goalkeeper, and it was an excellent display of his talent. simple as that.
It doesnt matter if he got the ball first man its dangerous play!
 
If the ref had incorrectly sent him off I'd be interested to have heard his explanation.
Hopefully it would be more in depth than the "it was dangerous play" guff that's been trotted out here.
 
Stop crying man, no foul. Every right to go for it. The games gone soft and it's people like you who are to blame.
My argument is its double standards and the rules are flawed if a outfiedl player wins the ball first then get the player with his studs up its a straight red so how can a keeper do that!

nope. its dangerous if he's not in control of his movements. he was, and therefore its not dangerous. sorry, but you're just wrong
So if hes in control he kneed him in the face on purpose then ,which is dangerous play.
 
I can see the argument on both sides but the question is can a keeper legally jump with his knee raised high or is it just one of those rules that doesn't get enforced?
 
I can see the argument on both sides but the question is can a keeper legally jump with his knee raised high or is it just one of those rules that doesn't get enforced?
They can do it responsibly to protect themselves when jumping for a cross ,but he jumped into someone with his knee it wasnt raising it to keep people off and away from him
 
It wasnt even a foul never mind he should be sent off! Great Goalkeeping.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Back
Top