Neuer should be off


Status
Not open for further replies.
Some bizarre arguments on here - it was 50/50, he won the ball etc. None of these things have anything to do with dangerous play which is the real issue. You can win the ball in a 50/50 tackle and still get sent off so please don't use these things in your argument.
 
It is obstruction. Read the laws
So higuain has obstructed neuer with his face as the pic shows hahahahahahahahahahahaaaaaaaahhhhhhaaaaaaaahhhaaaaa

Some bizarre arguments on here - it was 50/50, he won the ball etc. None of these things have anything to do with dangerous play which is the real issue. You can win the ball in a 50/50 tackle and still get sent off so please don't use these things in your argument.
It wasnt 50/50 man neuer shouldnt be going for that he nearly killed the fucker!
 
Great challenge. Won the ball because he's allowed to use his fists. Goalkeepers are taught to jump with their knees up, strikers are taught to get out the f***ing way. 50/50 in any other area of the pitch, which turns into an 80/20 when facing a goalkeeper. Natural advantage to the goalie, well played.
 
the main points are:

- higuain did not move towards neuer

- neuer moved towards higuain

- neuer jumped towards the ball, and higuian, with his knee head height and in the process of punching the ball, had to go through higuain, with his knee connecting with higuains head.

blatant and obvious foul


Logon or register to see this image

For me it could have gone either way and I could have understood it.

His knee didn't make contact with his head so we'll stop that right there.

He did jump into him a touch, like a coming together. It seems permissible for keepers as it happens all the time. They always jump out and into players with a knee raised and never ever get pulled up on it.

It looks worse because while Neuer can play it with a fist, Higuain has to use a head. It puts him in a more dangerous position but that doesn't mean the keeper can't go for it.

Could have gone either way really, have seen both given, but was never a red in a million years
 
Great challenge. Won the ball because he's allowed to use his fists. Goalkeepers are taught to jump with their knees up, strikers are taught to get out the f***ing way. 50/50 in any other area of the pitch, which turns into an 80/20 when facing a goalkeeper. Natural advantage to the goalie, well played.
fair play on your blatant wind up :lol:
 
Great challenge. Won the ball because he's allowed to use his fists. Goalkeepers are taught to jump with their knees up, strikers are taught to get out the f***ing way. 50/50 in any other area of the pitch, which turns into an 80/20 when facing a goalkeeper. Natural advantage to the goalie, well played.
Aye on crosses man ya f***ing clown
 
For me it could have gone either way and I could have understood it.

His knee didn't make contact with his head so we'll stop that right there.

He did jump into him a touch, like a coming together. It seems permissible for keepers as it happens all the time. They always jump out and into players with a knee raised and never ever get pulled up on it.

It looks worse because while Neuer can play it with a fist, Higuain has to use a head. It puts him in a more dangerous position but that doesn't mean the keeper can't go for it.

Could have gone either way really, have seen both given, but was never a red in a million years
Fully agree
 
So higuain has obstructed neuer with his face as the pic shows hahahahahahahahahahahaaaaaaaahhhhhhaaaaaaaahhhaaaaa


It wasnt 50/50 man neuer shouldnt be going for that he nearly killed the fucker!
I wasn't referring to the neuer challenge. I was simply saying 50/50 isn't a basis for an argument.
 
If @wakey wakey says obstruction isn't a real law as it is never applied. Then keepers are never applied when fouling strikers

By his own logic, it wasn't a foul. His logic changes to suit.
 
Nah I just remember overhearing the Wales youth goalkeeper coach repeatedly tell the goalies to 'get their knee up high'

It's their prerogative, get out of their way because hey hold the natural advantage.
 
Embarrasing people defending that like how the fuck is that 50/50 neuer has absolutly no right to challenge for that higuain is positioned himself so that challenge is illegal its like summit off the wwf man
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Back
Top