Neuer should be off


Status
Not open for further replies.
If a outfield player is shielding a ball can u go thru them to win the ball?
 
He was favoured going into the challange because of his longer reach (can use hands). He would be going in late if he was an outfield player, but he's not, and that advantage is rightly taken into account when refs deem which player has the advantage in a challenge involving a keeper. It's the other players responsibility to get out of the way if he doesn't fancy getting flattened.
 
If a outfield player is shielding a ball can u go thru them to win the ball?

If you get the ball first then contact is allowed.

It even happened in this game. Was between Higuain and Neuer iirc
 
Grow up. I'm arguing it as someone who has actually played football and knows how those sort of situations work. He got the ball, he used his natural advantage of a goalkeeper. Play on.

As it is, the ref actually gave a free kick in his favour.
if you cant win the ball without smashing your knee into someones face then do not go for that ball. it is that simple.
 
It wasnt a challenge and it wasnt a knee 6 ft in the air
It was a shoulder in the face, knockin him over so he could win the ball. Also in the penalty. That is dangerous play.

Leeds player seen red for it last season. Shoulder in the face is also dangerous play.

Absolutely no difference
 
Grow up. I'm arguing it as someone who has actually played football and knows how those sort of situations work. He got the ball, he used his natural advantage of a goalkeeper. Play on.

As it is, the ref actually gave a free kick in his favour.
Hahahahaha mate your not the onlyone whos played u know
 
if you cant win the ball without smashing your knee into someones face then do not go for that ball. it is that simple.
Cheers mate f***ing idiots these two like it just confirms to me that all of jstdfm knowledge comes off footy manager and fifa and has never played a competitive game in his life
 
It's not, hence the debate.

The ball was up in the air, in the goalie's box, the goalie won the ball first by punching it, as is his right. Play on.


Did you play netball?
in the process he could have knocked a player clean out with his knee.


same as saying a defender won a ball first from behind but followed through and took the striker out.

neauer came from behind and through a player to get the ball.


are you on a wind up? must be because someone surely cant defend that foul
 
Cheers mate f***ing idiots these two like it just confirms to me that all of jstdfm knowledge comes off footy manager and fifa and has never played a competitive game in his life

I played for Darlo and Boro until an injury and I have the opposite opinion to you.

Therefore, by your own admission, you must be wrong.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Back
Top