Neuer should be off


Status
Not open for further replies.
My argument is its double standards and the rules are flawed if a outfiedl player wins the ball first then get the player with his studs up its a straight red so how can a keeper do that!

for a start, neuer's studs werent up. his fingers were up, and fingers are hardly the same as studs. one are made of metal and unflexible, the other are fingers. I can sort of see where you're coming from, but its hardly the same situation
 
As keepers are allowed to handle the ball in the area, they have an advantage at taking a ball at height.
As such, they will go for a high ball earlier than an outfield player, and it's tough if one gets in the way.
Neuer was focused on getting the ball, he got the ball.

No foul for me.

I can slightly see the argument for a foul mind, but I cannot for the life of me see how it could ever be a red.
 
As keepers are allowed to handle the ball in the area, they have an advantage at taking a ball at height.
As such, they will go for a high ball earlier than an outfield player, and it's tough if one gets in the way.
Neuer was focused on getting the ball, he got the ball.

No foul for me.

I can slightly see the argument for a foul mind, but I cannot for the life of me see how it could ever be a red.
definitely a foul
definitely not a red, yellow at a push
 
Its dangerous play wich by todays new rules is a straight red hes going to kill someone neuer like hes just missed a few people like this in a earlier games outside of his area aswell one was near the byline!

Difference between brave and a irresponsible challenge he could of seriously hurt higuain
 
They can do it responsibly to protect themselves when jumping for a cross ,but he jumped into someone with his knee it wasnt raising it to keep people off and away from him
I think the problem is the law on serious foul play is open to massive discretion by the ref and should be clarified.
 
I Thought it was great keeping myself, he clearly got the ball and then they collided afterwards. Great clean out.

I laughed when it happened because I did something earlier to a striker in a game I played in today and he got booked for tripping me up after he fell :lol:
 
Has to be said it's blocks keepers can put there studs in the air of a knee at head hight but if you make any kind of contact with them it's a foul to the keeper.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Back
Top