Most dominant strikers and centre backs in league 1

I would agree in part...seemed after his sprog was born he went over the cliff.
So it is possible that he was playing above himself because it was his first full season and and couldn't maintain it for the whole season and also possible that he couldn't maintain it because of the additional responsibility of having a baby. The contract issue is also possible but it is certainly the least generous interpretation of his season's form.
 

BucketBiff

Striker
Our immobile centre midfield has an awful lot to do with our Shaky defence. Teams cottoned on early in the season that if you run with the ball with purpose through the midfield it’s likely that you will have a clear run at the CB’s.
 
Based on what? The lad was excellent up until he left.

His all round touch and play was actually good aswell, he was comfortably the best player in the division. Also made goals for himself like against Peterborough and Barnsley.
based on he rejected a contract offer that was at the amount he wanted then went and cleared his locker..people clear ther locker when they are leaving..he strung safc along to set the wage level for his next move..
 

molthemackem

Striker
So it is possible that he was playing above himself because it was his first full season and and couldn't maintain it for the whole season and also possible that he couldn't maintain it because of the additional responsibility of having a baby. The contract issue is also possible but it is certainly the least generous interpretation of his season's form.
Nah...I watched this lad play his first game in one of the league cup games about four years ago and thought he was one of the brightest things Sunderland has produced and I've seen quite a few in my time. He has however, not progressed sufficiently enough to say that any further improvement will be above his current level. It may well be due to his new family or the burden of a new contract ,who knows?, but i do not reckon any improvement will happen sad to say...This is the lads level.
 

officerbill

Central Defender
Why speak which such certainty about something that you couldn't possibly know?

The absolute opposite of what you said is just as realistic, even SD thinks he may have been able to do better at keeping him, he certainly underestimated the cost of unsuccessfully replacing.

This is a massive advocate for proper analysis, while SD may find any statistics boring, had he employed someone to use these findings, it may have alerted SD earlier to Maja's importance and prompted him to provide what was requested earlier in negotiation. It's of huge importance to question our own perception.
What 'analysis' are you talking about??
The club weighed up the pros and cons and with the confirmation that the player himself wanted to leave, they acted accordingly.
Hindsight is a great thing!!
 

Julio

Striker
We need a creative number 10 its as simple as that like. Honeyman offers nothing to that role.
 

Coeus

Striker
What 'analysis' are you talking about??
The club weighed up the pros and cons and with the confirmation that the player himself wanted to leave, they acted accordingly.
Hindsight is a great thing!!
The analysis on the front page.

The club ineffectively assessed the importance of Josh Maja and failed to offer what he is worth to us at an earlier point also as to how much it would cost to inefficiently replace him.

It's not the end of the world, football clubs make mistakes although you would like to think they would learn from them, I shan't hold my breath with the current decision makers though if their apparent disregard of analytics is to continue.

If when proved wrong you can only quote "hindsight...", well there is no arguing with that.

My point is, your opinion is just that.
 

Comeback_Kenwyne

Central Defender
Statistically Eaves and Marquis were the lads to watch. That's why I think it's an absolute no brainer why we should sign Eaves on a free when the lads only asking for £2000 a week.
This was a class post, but I haven't followed. Can somebody please tell me which of the dominant centre-back options we have a chance of signing - they should be the number one target.
 

Scorer

Winger
See Peterborough have had a bid accepted for Edmundson. Highly rated and one for the future, wouldn't be unhappy to see us move for him. Nelson, Heneghan and Tilt would be my main targets at centre half though.
 
Irrelevant to us as he'd have been worth a few hundred grand probably. If he'd wanted to stay, even till the end of the season he would have. People keep making it sound like the club forced him out, but they couldn't force him into signing a new contract so that doesn't ring true.
I'm sorry but the chairman quite publicly called him out and issued a stupid ultimatum. He may have stayed all season without that
 

The Fitter

Winger
Marcus Madison, the best no 10 in the league by a galaxy.....signing him is an absolute MUST!
& Eaves is worth 5k a week no bother, so give him it.
 

MackemRyan

Subs Bench
Gnanduillet from Blackpool really impressed me both times we've played against him this season. Surprised he's not near the top of that list.

No shock Eaves / Moore are where they are on that. Top quality strikers.
 

Top