MON furious with Catts..


Status
Not open for further replies.
I said it was a probable red. Either way, you hate a good sunderland player. It's a bit weird that like.

Its not weird

I think we could be a far better team without him

Just don't think someone of his style is actually required anymore
 
He's 24 now, and could play his role until he's 34. He seems to have had a long time, but if he learns by the time he's 26, he could be a good midfielder for another eight years.

He seems to have cut out the really vicious side of his game now, and is all the better for it. Who's to say he won't be able to remove these silly challenges from his game?

there never was a 'vicious' side to his game, the difference is he suits the way O'Neill plays and can do it without having to lunge in, under Cushion face he was just hoyed in the centre and left to fend for himself, of course a player is going to be less controlled with no discernible tactics for him to play.


that was an impression of all the whining fuckwits on here
 
He's still our best central midfielder, he just isn't captain material imo. Needs a sensible, even old experienced head, alongside him.
 
Its not weird

I think we could be a far better team without him

Just don't think someone of his style is actually required anymore

It is weird. He is a good player for us. Since O'Neill has come in the evidence is there for everyone to see.
 
The difference being, Scholes' tackling is always laughed off. "Haha little scholesey, he's never been able to tackle has he?"
Makes me sucking sick :evil:

It's not though is it - genericus points out up there he's been sent off plenty. It's only the pillocks like Hansen and Linekar and Sherarse who come out with that shite
 
Thank The Lord for that. Some one on the SMB knows what the hell they're talking about!

Wish I was intelligent enough to join the Catermole love in brigade... Boils my piss the arrogance of these t**ts. Guess I'll just have to accept that my opposing view means that I just "don't understand football" like they do.
 
He made a good run with the ball, it got slightly ahead of him and he tried to redeem himself with the challenge. Wasn't nasty or owt, just a bit over zealous, still a probable red mind. Some of the comments on here are a bit pathetic tbh. Why do supporters have to have a hate figure when theres nowt really to hate? :confused:

Because their more brain dead than Cattermole.
 
Scholes has been sent off 3 times more than Cattermole since 2001/02

considering some of the tackles Scholes has got away with it boggles the mind.

Not exactly a fair comparison seeing as Cattermole will have been only 13 or 14 in 2001.
 
He made a good run with the ball, it got slightly ahead of him and he tried to redeem himself with the challenge. Wasn't nasty or owt, just a bit over zealous, still a probable red mind. Some of the comments on here are a bit pathetic tbh. Why do supporters have to have a hate figure when theres nowt really to hate? :confused:

I guarantee you wouldn't be spouting this if we had lost. Along with a number of posters, you're letting the result of the game, affect your judgement of the sending off.
 
He made a good run with the ball, it got slightly ahead of him and he tried to redeem himself with the challenge. Wasn't nasty or owt, just a bit over zealous, still a probable red mind. Some of the comments on here are a bit pathetic tbh. Why do supporters have to have a hate figure when theres nowt really to hate? :confused:

Post of the night
 
It's not though is it - genericus points out up there he's been sent off plenty. It's only the pillocks like Hansen and Linekar and Sherarse who come out with that shite

its the game they play, they are midfield enforcers if you will, as much as i hate the term, Scholes, Keane, Cattermole are tough tackling mid fielders whos aim is to break up play, get the ball to the more attacking players, they are going to be more susceptible to getting Red Cards because of the more physical style of their play, they harry, they get the ball by hook or crook and distribute it to the players who are better on the ball.

The difference between them players and Catts despite the obvious step up in ability is they got forward and scored, but look at the like of Makelele, Viera, Cambiasso, Marcos Senna and Gattuso were prone to stupid rash tackles and getting sent off, were never prolific for midfielders but are revered for how they played.

Amazing what a foreign name can do for a players reputation, if any of those played here the precious twats on here would be having kittens

Not exactly a fair comparison seeing as Cattermole will have been only 13 or 14 in 2001.

its th only stats i can find, most seem to start in 2003
 
its the game they play, they are midfield enforcers if you will, as much as i hate the term, Scholes, Keane, Cattermole are tough tackling mid fielders whos aim is to break up play, get the ball to the more attacking players, they are going to be more susceptible to getting Red Cards because of the more physical style of their play, they harry, they get the ball by hook or crook and distribute it to the players who are better on the ball.

The difference between them players and Catts despite the obvious step up in ability is they got forward and scored, but look at the like of Makelele, Viera, Cambiasso, Marcos Senna and Gattuso were prone to stupid rash tackles and getting sent off, were never prolific for midfielders but are revered for how they played.

Amazing what a foreign name can do for a players reputation, if any of those played here the precious twats on here would be having kittens



its th only stats i can find, most seem to start in 2003

You can't seriously be comparing him to any of those players?
 
its the game they play, they are midfield enforcers if you will, as much as i hate the term, Scholes, Keane, Cattermole are tough tackling mid fielders whos aim is to break up play, get the ball to the more attacking players, they are going to be more susceptible to getting Red Cards because of the more physical style of their play, they harry, they get the ball by hook or crook and distribute it to the players who are better on the ball.

The difference between them players and Catts despite the obvious step up in ability is they got forward and scored, but look at the like of Makelele, Viera, Cambiasso, Marcos Senna and Gattuso were prone to stupid rash tackles and getting sent off, were never prolific for midfielders but are revered for how they played.

Amazing what a foreign name can do for a players reputation, if any of those played here the precious twats on here would be having kittens



its th only stats i can find, most seem to start in 2003

I agree. Actually I'm in the middle on this. My first thought when I heard he'll miss the derby was - "At least he can't get sent off during the derby!" :lol:
I haven't seen his tackle so...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Back
Top