Mcgeady


Status
Not open for further replies.
I slated him for the first half against Shrewsbury and was quite happy for parkinson to ship him out for the good of the team.

Seems to me the highs are high and the lows are low. If he can play a part in a team which he mostly has under Johnson then great.

I'm not sure the of the difference it would make over a season if you played mcgeady every game or diamond, be far better of financially mind.
I think he needs to like and respect the manager/ coach. Worked hard for Ross and played through injury, looked mostly finished for Parkinson and Bowyer. I’d have ditched him under Parkinson but delighted we didn’t.
 
It's a massive cause for celebration what he did in on Saturday. It is also a real treat in this division to see quality like he has on display for us. On form he is probably the most talented creative player in the league.His stats are starting to look phenomenal We are lucky to have him and let's hope we can keep him fit and focussed. Let's also hope that LJ keeps the front three as it allows him to excel. I do still worry when he does his tricks next to our box but with genius comes risk I guess.
The history of the story is complex though and none of us know exactly what happened. If he did bully younger players then there is no room for that. Im not sure I completely accept his version as the complete truth. Surely though there had to have been a better way to manage it than we did. Other senior players having a quiet word, Phil Parkinson having adult adult conversations like he did with Maguire, whole squad conversations, a return after a while in the cold. I don't know what happened but am certain its neither completely saint or sinner. My conclusion is that talent like his in this nightmare league simply has to be managed differently and with the benefit of hindsight, PP wasn't up to it.
 
I think he needs to like and respect the manager/ coach. Worked hard for Ross and played through injury, looked mostly finished for Parkinson and Bowyer. I’d have ditched him under Parkinson but delighted we didn’t.

I'm happy to do without to be honest.

In no way has he provided value for money in league 1, ross' teams played better without him. Johnson appears to be getting a song out of him.

If he is prepared to lower his wage and he fits in with a strategy and not throw any strops, fair enough.
 
I'm happy to do without to be honest.

In no way has he provided value for money in league 1, ross' teams played better without him. Johnson appears to be getting a song out of him.

If he is prepared to lower his wage and he fits in with a strategy and not throw any strops, fair enough.

Seems to me like the only one throwing the strop is you because he's totally proved you wrong 😂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Back
Top