McGeady


Status
Not open for further replies.
Pinning our hopes on this waste of space. I despair. 🙈

He's the 2020 version of Sean Thornton and Wahbi Khazri. And the same people are promoting him. Apparently a player's attitude is all down to the manager, and he need take no responsibility for it himself. No matter how many clubs he has flopped at, or how many managers bombed him out.
 
He's our best player. Simple as that.

He's the player with the most natural talent, without doubt. Whether that makes him our "best player" is a different argument.

I've already said on this thread that we've seen what happens when our main tactic is to give it to McGeady and hope he does something and it isn't great. If a manager could get that talent working in a team setup then it may be different but hardly anyone has managed to do that throughout his entire career.
 
In my opinion he can be, but similar to maguire he can be shite aswell!
Maguire is nowhere near the ability of Mcgeady.
He's the player with the most natural talent, without doubt. Whether that makes him our "best player" is a different argument.

I've already said on this thread that we've seen what happens when our main tactic is to give it to McGeady and hope he does something and it isn't great. If a manager could get that talent working in a team setup then it may be different but hardly anyone has managed to do that throughout his entire career.
You don't play at the highest level including Champions League without having something about you. Only something this squad could dream of. Got to get him in around the first X1.
 
Last edited:
Was it not established yesterday that due to salary cap restrictions they cannot afford to include him in the squad. Not withstanding that he can’t run.
If we can’t afford to add him that means we’re within 1.7 k of the total cap which means no signings over 21 in January without a substantial clear out. McGeady, Grigg, O’Brien and Graham joint first on the get shot list for me.
 
Who's better?
In terms of the team dynamic. Anybody who can put the yards in to do the work rate so that the midfield is not overrun.
If we can’t afford to add him that means we’re within 1.7 k of the total cap which means no signings over 21 in January without a substantial clear out. McGeady, Grigg, O’Brien and Graham joint first on the get shot list for me.
Precisely, I am not sure that has dawned on people. Jeff Bezos could be buying the club but he couldn’t spend his money on playing staff.
 
Last edited:
Maguire is nowhere near the ability of Mcgeady.

You don't play at the highest level including Champions League without having something about you. Only something this squad could dream of. Got to get him in around the first X1.

Alan Kennedy 18 months prior to signing for us was a European cup winner scoring the winning goal. At 34 he suddenly couldn't run, tackle, pass. Nobody has seen Aiden McGeady kick a football for over a year and at 34/35 having failed to make an impression at Charlton his Champions league experience a decade ago doesn't count for much. Lets see if he has the legs, the desire and commitment. I'm not so sure
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Back
Top