Major Major's Coleman poll - stay or go?

[dcl0sc]

A European Championship semi final with an average squad?

Take out Gareth Bale and that squad would have got nowhere near. He was blessed with one special player.... one!

 

[Mackem00]

Spot on mate
Though I would add that Watmore would have massively improved us.

Chris wouldn't.

 

[Ghost of Bagpuss]

Take out Gareth Bale and that squad would have got nowhere near. He was blessed with one special player.... one!

You think one player is capable of taking a poor team to the semi finals of the Euro Championships, careful before you give your answer as it could be embarrassing.

 

[dcl0sc]

You think one player is capable of taking a poor team to the semi finals of the Euro Championships, careful before you give your answer as it could be embarrassing.

Maradona single handedly won the world cup for the Argies. So yes!

 

[chunkyshanhawk53]

Maradona single handedly won the world cup for the Argies. So yes!

Messi hasn’t

Yet

 

[dcl0sc]

Messi hasn’t

Yet

True!

 

[Ghost of Bagpuss]

Maradona single handedly won the world cup for the Argies. So yes!

Give over, a huge influence for sure but not on his own.

Messi hasn’t

Yet

Neither has Ronaldo

 

[dcl0sc]

Give over, a huge influence for sure but not on his own.

Everything went through or was influenced by him! He was a genius!

 

[hefty em]

Comprehensive.

 

[Ghost of Bagpuss]

Everything went through or was influenced by him! He was a genius!

Agreed he was but imho no better than either Messi or Ronaldo?

 

[The Bridge Lad]

Comprehensive.

Seemingly, but the no vote is gathering momentum. I'm sure it was around 15% a few days ago.

It was 139 less than 2 mins ago

 

[dcl0sc]

Agreed he was but imho no better than either Messi or Ronaldo?

IMO he is, unless the other two win a world cup single handedly for their country.

 

[AC Mack]

You think one player is capable of taking a poor team to the semi finals of the Euro Championships, careful before you give your answer as it could be embarrassing.

You're saying the manager took them there, then criticising someone for saying a player took them there?

If it's between Coleman and Bale as to who had the biggest impact on taking Wales that far, there's only one answer.

 

[Ghost of Bagpuss]

You're saying the manager took them there, then criticising someone for saying a player took them there?

If it's between Coleman and Bale as to who had the biggest impact on taking Wales that far, there's only one answer.

Give over, great player but one player can not make up for the deficiencies of an entire team.

 

[chunkyshanhawk53]

Give over, great player but one player can not make up for the deficiencies of an entire team.

Let’s also not pretend he is that incredible a player

Real are looking to peddle him

 

[AC Mack]

Give over, great player but one player can not make up for the deficiencies of an entire team.

You only have to win a few games to get to a knockout competition semi-final.

 

[Ghost of Bagpuss]

You only have to win a few games to get to a knockout competition semi-final.

So great Real have started him just 16 times this season.

You only have to win a few games to get to a knockout competition semi-final.

Somet England seem to manage to do consistently

 

[AC Mack]

So great Real have started him just 16 times this season.

What's that got to do with anything?

 

[Ghost of Bagpuss]

What's that got to do with anything?

He is such a great player he has managed only 16 starts maybe?

 

[AC Mack]

He is such a great player he has managed only 16 starts maybe?

You said he was a great player, not me.