London Climate Disruption

Discussion in 'SMB' started by Bishop Boy, Apr 15, 2019.

  1. duff_man

    duff_man Striker

    Last year during the climate change protests one of the memorials on whitehall was graffitied, think it was the women in war memorial but might be wrong about that.

    Right to protest isn’t an absolute right so it can be denied, as can right to life.
     
  2. CatRyan

    CatRyan Striker

    On what grounds can the right to life be denied?
     
  3. duff_man

    duff_man Striker

    Someone lawfully shot and killed by police
     
    lurker likes this.
  4. Leon Solent

    Leon Solent Midfield

    A dusting with Agent Orange would sort them out.
     
    ouro likes this.
  5. CatRyan

    CatRyan Striker

    I wouldn't describe that as denying someone the right to life.
    It is just that the right to life of others when threatened must be upheld.
     
  6. duff_man

    duff_man Striker

    They are being killed, that is denying them their right to life.

    Before you start spouting bollocks about something you know the square root of fuck all about have a look up of absolute, qualified and limited rights under the Human Rights Act.
     
  7. CatRyan

    CatRyan Striker

    Police do not have the right to decide to deny people the right to life.
    They have the duty to preserve life.

    If you can't see the difference you need to have a quiet moment to reflect
     
  8. Tadger

    Tadger Striker

    Is there any kind of consideration for emergency vehicles?
     
  9. Bishop Boy

    Bishop Boy Striker

    Don't be silly.
     
  10. duff_man

    duff_man Striker

    Whether you like it or not they do, it is then upto a coroner or inquest to decide if the taking of that life was lawful.

    You need to have a read up on things before offering your opinion.

    Last year an ambulance was trying to get through one of their blockades. They held a vote to see if they should allow it through, there was then a series of following votes to decide if the initial vite was fair and representative, Brexit has nothing on these lot!!
    The ambulance did get through after 45 minutes though
     
    Last edited: Apr 15, 2019
    Bishop Boy and Leon Solent like this.
  11. heroesof73

    heroesof73 Striker

     
    yorkyexile likes this.
  12. CatRyan

    CatRyan Striker

    No whether you like it or not the police are invested with the duty to preserve life not to deny life. That is not semantics. It is important law.
     
  13. duff_man

    duff_man Striker

    Right to life is not absolute, are you denying this or just doing your usual thing of arguing about something you don’t know about?

    Like I said have a read of the human rights act, you might educate yourself.
     
  14. Stubbs ftm

    Stubbs ftm Winger

    Scruffy twats want to get a job instead of being dicks.
    I bet it's the same people who turn up to every protest and rally going
     
  15. James

    James Striker

    They're let through, as is anyone on a bicycle. The taxi protests have more of an impact on emergency services.
     
  16. CatRyan

    CatRyan Striker

    The police do not have the right to deny life they have a duty to preserve life.
     
  17. duff_man

    duff_man Striker

    I didn’t say they had the right to deny life. I said the right to life is not absolute and so can be legally violated, a firearms officer was an example I gave. Another example would be a health trust refusing to fund life saving treatment to someone.

    Like I have said several times now, read up on things before trying to give your ill informed opinion.
     
  18. Hulkster

    Hulkster Striker

    Given that the UK's emissions account for less than 1% of the total, then even if we reverted to a pre-industrial society and let the tens of millions of people die which that would entail, it would make absolutely zero difference to climate change whether it is a theory you believe in or not.
     
    KatManDont and NodsNeph like this.
  19. CatRyan

    CatRyan Striker

    You can't grasp a basic concept so I dread to think what you make of a whole treatise.

    Police are not invested with the right to deny life they have a duty to preserve life.

    Let that sink in.
     
  20. duff_man

    duff_man Striker

    I take it you still haven’t read up on the HRA yet then? Do that then you will see where your argument falls down spectacularly.
     

Share This Page