Just watched the Noble foul again


Status
Not open for further replies.
The thing is, it's the same referees getting decisions 'wrong' AGAINST SAFC all of the time.
It's not just that they're missing things - they're missing things in the SAME direction.
Is it any wonder people are questioning their honesty?

Apart from the games this season can't remember him reffing us before hardly call that all the time.

As for other refs either the bad decisions against us are concidence or the refs have a meeting at the start of the season and stay lets get Sunderland.

Only one of the reasons makes any sense.
 
I don't read the majority of your posts, they're all basically the same so I assumed you'd spent the whole thread defending the referee, so apologies if I saw something that wasn't there, or indeed, completely and wilfully ignored something that was.

Not that particular ref mate,refs in general.
 
Yeah agree mate,I believe I already said it was a really bad mistake,and he should be marked down for it.

You said you would like to know what his excuse was for not giving it,I just said his excuse would be pretty obvious only thing it could of been,although of the evidence you have provide yes flimsily excuse.

He must of thought a accidental coming together which of course he would be clearly wrong.
fair do's, again though mate eyes on the ball and you can clearly see that is no accidental coming together. Then just to add something else, it isn't an offence for Noble to be in the way of Borini, it is an offence if he moves in his path. Since he gave a free kick, it is unlikely to have been accidental and more of a deliberate act
 
Last edited:
fair do's, again though mate eyes on the ball and you can clearly see that is no accidental coming together. Then just to add something else, it isn't an offence for Noble to be in the way of Borini, it is an offence if he moves in his path. Since he gave a free kick, it is unlikely to have been accidental and a deliberate act

Yeah fair enough you have time to think of these responses and that makes sense,the ref does not have time to weigh all this up,just goes of his initial instincts,in this case they were very wrong.
 
Apart from the games this season can't remember him reffing us before hardly call that all the time.

As for other refs either the bad decisions against us are concidence or the refs have a meeting at the start of the season and stay lets get Sunderland.

Only one of the reasons makes any sense.
I remember Swarbrick from last season.
I'm not saying all refs are against us, but maybe Swarbrick, Marriner & Friend all have a personal bias against SAFC. I wouldn't rule out that scenario
 
Apart from the games this season can't remember him reffing us before hardly call that all the time.

As for other refs either the bad decisions against us are concidence or the refs have a meeting at the start of the season and stay lets get Sunderland.

Only one of the reasons makes any sense.
They aren't the only two reasons, it isn't an either or ... that's very simplistic.
 
Does the ref assessors marks get published any were .? Also the club shud not be putting up with him why have we had him twice if he can tell the fa why that was not a booking
 
They aren't the only two reasons, it isn't an either or ... that's very simplistic.

Yeah possibly,but IMO,the mistake on Saturday was very bad mistake that all.

Think extremely unlikely that 3 or 4 refs go out of their way just to give bad decisions just against Sunderland don't you?
 
It wasnt a straight red, but it was a blatant bodycheck where he actually jumped into his path. Lens deserved his 2 yellows but it doesnt excuse not giving noble a red.
 
Thought it was a bad one at the time but that video is ridiculous. How can the referee justify not booking him, absolute bullshit. Same ref who seen Williams handball against us but bizarrely claimed his arms were down by his side, when they were really up near his chest.

Staggering how many of these game changing decisions have went against us already this season like.
 
Does the ref assessors marks get published any were .? Also the club shud not be putting up with him why have we had him twice if he can tell the fa why that was not a booking
They'll be published in a masonic lodge somewhere no doubt. We won't have any members.
 
What f***ing somes up this thread up is nearly everyone bar none on here say that Noble clearly body checked him,some say forearm smashed him.

So in other words everyone agrees Noble cheated.

However how many people have called Noble a cheat and slagged him off,next to no one.

The culture of football is all wrong lets not call a cheat a cheat,let's call somebody not spotting the cheat,the cheat!
 
Last edited:
Swarbrick and Friend seem to have a negative agenda regarding SAFC. No way on earth could their consistent decisions these two give against us be put down to chance..

Now why do you think they would risk their entire careers by picking on one club? Or do you think the Premier League / FA / UEFA / Fifa are in on it as well and are all in 'cahoots'. Like an enigma, wrapped inside a mystery inside a riddle type of thing. Is Marriner in on it as well and Lee Mason? Do you reckon its a funny hand shake type of pullava?

The truth is out there
 
It wasnt a straight red, but it was a blatant bodycheck where he actually jumped into his path. Lens deserved his 2 yellows but it doesnt excuse not giving noble a red.
I've just watched it again on SAFSEE, and tbh it looks like a borderline red to me, which means at least a yellow,
he body checked Borini cos they couldn't do owt with him on that run. The thing is, the refs are supposed to stamp this out.
 
Fair enough I was just pointing out that how we perform makes miles more difference who the ref is,I would not care if we had exactly the same ref every game,it the players performing that's important to me.

Rubbish!!! if a ref makes it impossible to pressure the ball because he keeps booking our players it makes a massive difference. Seeing the opposition getting away Scott free for identical stuff and heads drop.

Of course they can make mistakes. However when they are CONSISTENTLY 'making mistakes' week in week out against the same team then their judgement will rightly get called into question.

What I can't get my head around is people like you bending over backwards to defend their every move. What do you get out of it?

Attention on a message board, gives them a sense of importance.
 
Yeah possibly,but IMO,the mistake on Saturday was very bad mistake that all.

Think extremely unlikely that 3 or 4 refs go out of their way just to give bad decisions just against Sunderland don't you?
Again, you've gone simplistic ... go out of their way? That's nothing I've said or suggested.

I'll leave you all to it and hopefully it'll get resolved.
 
Of course, the incident being discussed wasn't too difficult at all though was it? It was very easy, even straightforward ... basic.

How many times have you got to see so called 'easy' decisions getting missed by every single official who has ever took part in the game before you realise it's not as easy as it seems?

Up and down the country this week alone fans for most teams will be screaming about refs missing easy decisions. Yes I agree Noble should have went but on a wider point it should be clear to anyone things are not as easy as a lot of people claim they are
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Back
Top