JD or KP

[WHO WAS PHONE]

I know Phillips did more for Sunderland, But if we had Defoe at that time, do things work out differently?

Obviously I love them both but I'm quitehigh and me and me can't decide what would have happened. I reckon Quinn might not have worked with Defoe at the time, but that Defoewas a littlebit younger given that he fell in love with the lads would have spend the majority of his career here

 

[Summerbee]

KP

 

[robbied1]

Quinn would have been perfect for Defoe in that era. Quinn wasnt selfish, defoe would have loved all the knock downs

 

[beachball]

Defoe’s twice the player.

KP was poor and overrated outside of one season

 

[Ale taster]

Defoe’s twice the player.

KP was poor and overrated outside of one season

This has got to be some kind of a wind up

 

[Red]

Defoe’s twice the player.

KP was poor and overrated outside of one season

Lunatic.

I honestly think its unfair to compare them. Both exceeded our expectations.

 

[Wayne The Punk]

Phillips, in the box and outside the box, best striker I have seen at the club in 50 years

Defoe was also very good, and we were watching him at the back end of his career. He is now farming sheep in Scotland

 

[BIG MAL]

Phillips, in the box and outside the box, best striker I have seen at the club in 50 years

Defoe was also very good, and we were watching him at the back end of his career. He is now farming sheep in Scotland

I'd seriously have either right now.

 

[Wayne The Punk]

I'd seriously have either right now.

So would I, I think both of them will be quicker than our current 2 over 10 yards, the important part, and also have movement, remember that?

 

[barts45]

Kp

 

[Richie K]

Both legends in my eyes.

 

[tonyfromalnwick]

KP was poor and overrated outside of one season

Mag

 

[Redby-lad]

Defoe’s twice the player.

KP was poor and overrated outside of one season

Was that one season the one where he broke Brian Cloughs record with 35 goals in the Championship or the one where he won the European golden Boot with 30 Premier League goals?

KP all day long.

 

[Kid Galahad]

It's like choosing your favourite child! Loved them both and both were exactly what we needed at the time they were here, SKP edges it but he had Quinny, poor JD was doing it by himself most of the time.

 

[Gonzo Mackem]

Remember when we all hated JD.

 

[Vauxie]

Both left us in the lurch, pair of wankers and not on my leg end list just ex players.

 

[Eggman]

KP was poor and overrated outside of one season

The 35 goal season, the 24 goals but missed 4 months or the 30 goal season ?

Both left us in the lurch, pair of wankers and not on my leg end list just ex players.

Another wind up merchant - embarrassing himself

 

[Freddie the Greek]

Defoe’s twice the player.

KP was poor and overrated outside of one season

Off yer tits.

 

[Wise Man Says]

Phillips, without a doubt.

 

[CheersMarra84]

Defoe’s twice the player.

KP was poor and overrated outside of one season

I know you’re on a bite, nobody can be that thick but if Phillips had the consistent service that Defoe had at Spurs he’d be talked of in a different light. The bloke was a natural goal scorer.