Is the Haka cultural appropriation?

Discussion in 'SMB' started by HellsBells, Nov 10, 2018 at 3:08 PM.

  1. zwartekat

    zwartekat Striker

    It's the only way to make rugby interesting.
     
    Black Cat Gypsy likes this.
  2. Goat Eyes

    Goat Eyes Striker

    Ouch aye, yae ken.
     
  3. yorkyexile

    yorkyexile Striker

    when does celebration of others cultures become cultural appropriation?
     
  4. humbug

    humbug Striker

    my favourite haka.
     
  5. qixman

    qixman Central Defender

    Cultural appropriation is an invention of the loony snowflake generation and does not exist.
     
    gazc24, kamaras-tash, Boz33 and 10 others like this.
  6. jackynutmeg

    jackynutmeg Winger

    Load of shite
    Why the fuck do the oppo have to stand and watch? I would turn my back on it
     
    Fusco and Bishop Boy like this.
  7. I think they look like a complete bunch of fannies. Just saying like.:rolleyes:
     
  8. Well I’m not sure. But I was thinking of that lass who got lamblasted (sic) for wearing a Chinese dress to her prom a while back or someone who got shouted at for putting cornrows in her hair, and I was watching a load of white blokes doing a Maori dance just there and wondered how they can get away with it when others can’t.

    (For the record, I don’t think my two examples are cultural appropriation)
     
    Black Cat Gypsy and yorkyexile like this.
  9. Pat Boone
     
  10. Is it cultural appropriation when a man of Asian heritage runs my local fish and chip shop? Think it's all a load of bollocks myself like, like people having a go at Jamie Oliver for doing a cookbook with recipes from Jamaica or whatever, madness to criticise stuff like that when there's actual racism around
     
    ISOE II, scott934, riffraff and 3 others like this.
  11. double maxim

    double maxim Midfield

    Celebration of a nations cultural heritage surely.
     
  12. I agree with you, although the Jamie Oliver thing I get because he’s not just made some Jamaican recipes, he’s made up some recipes that aren’t actually Jamaican at all, and then called them Jamaican to cash in on Jamaicanness.
     
    Guinness Guzzler likes this.
  13. David Carradine in Kung Fu
     
    riffraff likes this.
  14. mcq10

    mcq10 Striker

    Pisses me off that they are allowed to do it.

    It’s only a recent thing
     
    HellsBells likes this.
  15. It’s celebration of a heritage that isn’t theirs, isn’t it? There’s only about half the team who can claim it’s their heritage by the looks of things.

    For the record, I think cultural appropriation is used as an excuse for a load of shit, but the point I’m making is that if people use it for stuff like prom dresses and hairstyles then how is the Haka not??

    This. We should make summat up and just do it in response. Or turn our backs (I know it’s been done before but I don’t see why we have to “respect” it).
     
    CEF, Bishop Boy and SAFCOldie like this.
  16. kossoff

    kossoff Winger

    Add to that, he's a cock.
     
    HellsBells likes this.
  17. humbug

    humbug Striker

    i love it. it does have quite a history mind before the rugby connection.
     
  18. duff_man

    duff_man Striker

    Out of respect and basic manners I would guess.
     
    matt228, Mackem00 and PhilSAFC like this.
  19. We should make one up and make them watch us then. Why is it only one way?
     

Share This Page