Honest opinions of Sinclair ?


Status
Not open for further replies.
Good squad player and will be 3rd or 4th choice with a fully fit team. He’s our only striker with pace....
 
Good squad player and will be 3rd or 4th choice with a fully fit team. He’s our only striker with pace....
The problem is I don't see him as a centre forward and needs the ball played into channels. The only player of that type is Wyke. Maja will be able to do that role in a couple of years time as his strength increases.
 
He seems to work hard enough but isn't massively holding up play or winning many headers. Seems to get an easy ride from the same people who are quick to jump on Maja's back for not putting himself about? Maja is streets ahead of him in terms of quality and even bringing people into play but gets a lot more stick than Sinclair because Sinclair looks busier.
 
There's a reason for that! It's obvious he hasn't got what it takes. Liverpool got shot of him and So did Watford. He's struggling in division one. It's not the quality of the balls to him that's the problem he can't judge the flight of the ball, he can't control the ball to his feet and hold it up. He's ineffective. When Maja came on in his place we created more.
He’s 21 for starters, and clearly not a lone hold up play kind of forward. Ever think we created more because they were 2 down and really having to push on to create something? I don’t think he is a world beater but he has shown enough glimpses in 3 starts for us to suggest he could be a decent footballer imo.
 
Must admit he's flattered to deceive so far he doesn't seem to have much about him he isn't particularly quick he isn't a goalscorer and his all round contribution isn't great

For someone who was very highly rated at Liverpool I really can't see a top player in him

I also don't think he will make a premier League player
Good player. End of story!
 
Not very impressed and struggle to see what his strengths are. People seem to accept a player just because he puts himself about a bit - Honeyman is another.

Sinclair could be easily replaced for someone that would offer more. I’d give Kimpioka a shot personally as he may be young but this is the league to get him started in
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Back
Top