Honest opinions of Sinclair ?


Status
Not open for further replies.
I think he’s a decent player. He needs more time. He’s full of work and never stops running. He’s a good player to have in the squad.
 
good option. nice to have a player on loan who works his socks off. will never be a 20+ goal a season player but has a big role to play the rest of this season.
 
Wins zero in the air (often doesn't even jump). Can't keep hold of the ball. Can't go past his man.

There is no happier clapper than me but all he does is provide an annoyance to the opposition defence.
 
Did he? That explains it then, ha ha. From my vantage point (East Stand, near the South Stand 18 yard box) with low sun in my dodgy eyes I thought he'd fluffed it! Apologies to Mr Maja!

If it’s the one I’m thinking of then I thought it was a cert but the defender got something on it which diverted it off the path it was taking to Maja.
 
Must admit he's flattered to deceive so far he doesn't seem to have much about him he isn't particularly quick he isn't a goalscorer and his all round contribution isn't great



For someone who was very highly rated at Liverpool I really can't see a top player in him

I also don't think he will make a premier League player

Not quick !!!!
 
This is early days, and probably haven't seen enough to properly judge, but...

In terms of his career prospects, I'm not sure he'll amount to much. He's a 22 year old, who cost his PL parent club 4m quid. Hhe's on loan at a League 1 team where isn't even 1st choice, and he isn't scoring goals when he plays. He's ok. He's reasonably quick, reasonably mobile and will put a shift in. But he's not a goal threat, he's not a very intelligent or skilful player, he's not great at leading the line, he's a bit clumsy and isn't a natural no 9, and he's absolute shit out wide.

I think he's an adequate stand in/sub for Maja, but I couldn't care less if he stays or goes at the end of the season, from what I've seen (so far, it is still early days!)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Back
Top