To be fair to Grant, he started really well, we scored a number of times from his deliveries. Then he fell away, but remember he found out that his mother was seriously ill and she eventually passed away. That would effect all of us.
Dylan McGeouch
- Thread starter Scotlands number 9
- Start date
Wicksy
Winger
Always there to receive the ball when team mates are under pressure, he never hides. We haven't seen anywhere near the best of him - let's pass judgment on him if he manages a long run of games
1more
Striker
What player have you been watching in McGeouch? It's not the same player as I've saw.
Even in his vintage Grant is far superior to McGeouch. Grant bring a cool and calming influence to the midfield, he also competes. He can pass it long and short and also looking to pass it forward.
McGeouch does none of that.
I'm not waiting around hopeful players come good. I think you have an image of the player you think he is but he hasn't shown anything if it.
Hes very limited and not fit to lace Grant's boots
Last edited:
Scootsie
Striker
Absolutely no argument from me that Leadbitter has quality on the ball, I just think he becomes a bit of a passenger when we don’t have possession.
Boyceyyy
Midfield
Stop talking shite, man.
1more
Striker
Get legs around him then. McGeough isn't the answer
You must be another who knows nowt about football
Wicksy
Winger
Were you at Rochdale away? Just wondering what you thought of McGeoch then? Even you who knows everything about football must have been just a little impressed by his performance?
1more
Striker
No I wasnt there. I do know a player when see one and McGeough isn't a player.
Infact I'd goes as far as hes a coward on the ball. He doesn't take to game by the scruff of the neck. He doesn't tackle doesn't compete for headers. Doesn't get forward and very very rarely pass the ball forward.
I am sorry I missed him do all that in the Rochdale game. What about the rest of the games hes played
Wicksy
Winger
Its pointless arguing with you, it's all about opinions and I also like to think that I know a player. Strange that our best points haul did come in his "other games" I'll leave it at that
Billy Batts
Striker
No where near leadbitter? f***ing hell, I'll say no more.
You obviously know fuck all. It's obvious.
Last edited:
Hull_Mackem
Striker
He was the best player or one of in every game he played. One of his worst performances was last night to be honest.
AC Mack
Striker
I read someone say McGeouch was 'immense' against Rochdale and Accrington the other day.
I chuckled.
Who was??
Last edited:
1more
Striker
I'm sorry but I'm not buying this whole McGeouch is the new Xavi thing.
No one will convince me otherwise.
No one will convince me otherwise.
McGeouch?
Hull_Mackem
Striker
I'm sorry but I'm not buying this whole McGeouch is the new Xavi thing.
No one will convince me otherwise.
Yes. Criminally underused in my opinion. Only is an opinion though, yours is as valid as mine. (Just that I'm right and you're wrong
McGeouch?
Wearside Wanderer II
Striker
Looks like aberdeen have pipped Hibs to the signing of funso Ojo so Mcgeoch looks out imo
Ball retention is always important no matter what league we are in , last season we gave the ball away far too much ,
McGeough is good at being available to take the ball and keep it , it's up to fellow midfielders or players further up the pitch to make themselves available . When he passes the ball backwards it's not always his fault the main thing is not to surrender possession , without the ball the opponents threat is minimised , as a holding midfielder this is a positive not a negative , a change of playing formation should improve his passing options.
AC Mack
Striker
That's a negative approach, not a positive one.
