Tom
Striker
The more I watch it, the more I think this is what happened.Not playing the advantage was wrong for two reasons. Firstly, Altidore could well have brushed Sagna off and gone on to score (which he did). The other thing was that it could very easily have carried on into the penalty area. I have a feeling that he was terrified of giving another penalty and so blew up before he had to make that decision - in other words he bottled it. IMO I'm not convinced that he would have given a red card if Altidore had gone down under the challenge, but he should have shown the red card, mainly because the ball went into the net - in a way it would have softened the blow.