Bardo


Status
Not open for further replies.
Proved here and at Spurs (where Bardsley wouldn't get a game) he isn't. One poor season at Villa where most struggled under an inept defensive manager doesn't make him worse.

Hugely over rated in his time here, never got the love in for him.

Average at Spurs, crap at Villa.

We'll never agree on this so we'll have to agree to disagree.
 
Hugely over rated in his time here, never got the love in for him.

Average at Spurs, crap at Villa.

We'll never agree on this so we'll have to agree to disagree.

Wasn't at all, he merely came here and proved what Bardsley lacks, though obviously he's not the complete footballer himself.

Bardsley is a trier and an all rounder. He's as good going forward as he is defensively, which isn't very. His defensive work is vastly overrated because he tries hard and chucks himself into tackles, when actually it's average at best.

Hutton due to his style leads him to be stretched defensively at times, but what he can give going forward is what teams aspiring to be good need and what someone like Larsson could desperately use. He's just come off the back of a season where everyone struggled at Villa and he was restrained from doing what he does best, hence he suffered as much as anyone.

There's no real competition to who's been the best player between them both over the last 4/5 years, because it's Hutton by a country mile.
 
Wasn't at all, he merely came here and proved what Bardsley lacks, though obviously he's not the complete footballer himself.

Bardsley is a trier and an all rounder. He's as good going forward as he is defensively, which isn't very. His defensive work is vastly overrated because he tries hard and chucks himself into tackles, when actually it's average at best.

Hutton due to his style leads him to be stretched defensively at times, but what he can give going forward is what teams aspiring to be good need and what someone like Larsson could desperately use. He's just come off the back of a season where everyone struggled at Villa and he was restrained from doing what he does best, hence he suffered as much as anyone.

There's no real competition to who's been the best player between them both over the last 4/5 years, because it's Hutton by a country mile
.

I'm your opinion, certainly not in mine, as I've said we'll agree to disagree.
 
I'm your opinion, certainly not in mine, as I've said we'll agree to disagree.

aside from Villa fans opinion, who certainly didn't rate Bardsley, what do you believe Bardsley has that Hutton hasn't and why do you feel Bardsley fits into our side better than Hutton would?
 
Although I agree Hutton is very shite, I would still say he's the best RB we've had at the club Post Drummaville takeover, that's shocking. :eek:

Puts into perspective the shite we've had to put up with over the last 6 years really.
 
Bardsley's a better defender, Hutton is better going forward IMO

debatable tbf although Hutton has been fairly terrible for Villa, in his loan spell here he complimented the team fantastically and much better than Bardsley who isn't defensively great anyway.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Back
Top