Another rubbish ref


Status
Not open for further replies.
Yes I seen the match yesterday and he was poor. I sm not shocked that you can't remember the game where these refs have good games. Always tend to be the way with you lot
I dont want to remember a refs performances, thats the whole point. Unfortunately because they are regularly bad we do.
 
You said that I didnt. If they all ref like Marriner and Madeley they need to go. But they dont, some get it right most of the time, these two didnt. Marriner is poor every time we see him.

Yet Marriner gets chosen for big games and European games so logic suggests he is lot lot better than you think,and logic suggests the people who know better than you and me think he is a good ref.
 
Yet Marriner gets chosen for big games and European games so logic suggests he is lot lot better than you think,and logic suggests the people who know better than you and me think he is a good ref.
This is what you said two weeks ago. No he shouldnt be picked if he regularly gets it wrong, which he does, and proven to, when he refs our games. That last one here was shocking.
If the best they have is him, the rest must be dire.
 
This is what you said two weeks ago. No he shouldnt be picked if he regularly gets it wrong, which he does, and proven to, when he refs our games. That last one here was shocking.
If the best they have is him, the rest must be dire.

He has obivosly got a lot of decisions right to get picked for them games it's just common sense

You have still not answered the question of why you think refs get a lot of decisions wrong in every league.

Surely there is more to it that they all shit?

Surely you must admit to get promoted in the first place they must have done a lot of good games?
 
Last edited:
You have still not answered the question of why you think refs get a lot of decisions wrong in every league.

Surely there is more to it that they all shit?

Surely you must admit to get promoted in the first place they must have done a lot of good games?
I dont know I didnt promote them. I don't know why they make bad decisions but I didnt say they were all poor either. Marriner is and Madley is. From the agreement on here Im not alone in that.
 
I dont know I didnt promote them. I don't know why they make bad decisions but I didnt say they were all poor either. Marriner is and Madley is. From the agreement on here Im not alone in that.

I honestly think your argument is farcical I really do, what you are saying is you saw Madley have a bad game yesterday that's fair enough, however you have no idea whatsoever how he has performed in his previous 99 games, the same to a certain extent with Marriner maybe a few more games.

Do you not think to make a fair appraisal of anybody's performance in anything you need to take into account all their performances.

I am not saying Madley is a good ref, I have no idea not seen enough of him and neither have you.

The people who appoint them have analysis of their every game and are experts in the field yet a fan in the stand who has watched a tiny tiny percentage of their games apparently knows more than these experts.

Sorry mate but that argument makes no sense whatsoever.
 
Last edited:
He was awful, even the pva chance 1st half, he was a mile offside

Can't blame the ref for offside decisions - that's up to the linesman. FWIW on that call the linesman was at the far side of the stadium and might have thought Vic's flick on actually was actually played by a defender.
 
I honestly think your argument is farcical I really do, what you are saying is you saw Madley have a bad game yesterday that's fair enough, however you have no idea whatsoever how he has performed in his previous 99 games, the same to a certain extent with Marriner maybe a few more games.

Do you not think to make a fair appraisal of anybody's performance in anything you need to take into account all their performances.

I am not saying Madley is a good ref, I have no idea not seen enough of him and neither have you.

The people who appoint them have analysis of their every game and are experts in the field yet a fan in the stand who has watched a tiny tiny percentage of their games apparently knows more than these experts.

Sorry mate but that argument makes no sense whatsoever.
Sorry Ive had enough if this. The ref was rubbish indefensible. Theres no argument its a fact. Get a life and accept the fact you and your refereeing pals arent very good. Ffs
 
Sorry Ive had enough if this. The ref was rubbish indefensible. Theres no argument its a fact. Get a life and accept the fact you and your refereeing pals arent very good. Ffs

Think I have had enough too,I have tried to get you to see logic and common sense,but can see I am wasting my time!!

By the way I have always thought I am a canny player.
 
Can't blame the ref for offside decisions - that's up to the linesman. FWIW on that call the linesman was at the far side of the stadium and might have thought Vic's flick on actually was actually played by a defender.
Refs can give offsides aswell, between them it was blatantly obvious he was offside
 
This is as tedious as the early leavers thread, they same posters spouting the same shite attempting to defend yet another wank refereeing performance, how and why they feel the need to try and defend the useless bastards is beyond me.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Back
Top