Alfie not wanted


Status
Not open for further replies.
:lol:

You don't even know what you are talking about man! I bet you didn't even watch him, mackembhoy showing you up for what you are.

you think alfir is better than cattermole, you can try and avoid the subject but you said it:lol::lol: can't take that back marra

mavrias better than Johnson I bet too?
 
you just said that before recently you thought alfie was better than cattermole :lol::lol:

and you call me an idiot, christ all mighty, that was one of the worst posts in the history of the SMB

Maybe you should read the posts before going all shouty?

I said Catts was a liability and not that good not that long back, and he was. He has improved loads lately. At the time when Catts was being sent off and playing shit, yeah I would have put Alfie in instead. I bet quite a few on here would have as well.

So tell me, in the last 2 or so seasons what exactly has Catts done? Injured all the time, plenty of red cards, mistakes leading to goals, yellow cards within 5 minutes ruling him out of the rest of the game, any goals or assists (bar his last one)?

Take the rose tinted geggs off man.
 
Maybe you should read the posts before going all shouty?

I said Catts was a liability and not that good not that long back, and he was. He has improved loads lately. At the time when Catts was being sent off and playing shit, yeah I would have put Alfie in instead. I bet quite a few on here would have as well.

So tell me, in the last 2 or so seasons what exactly has Catts done? Injured all the time, plenty of red cards, mistakes leading to goals, yellow cards within 5 minutes ruling him out of the rest of the game, any goals or assists (bar his last one)?

Take the rose tinted geggs off man.

:lol::lol::oops:

No he didnt. What a load of shite that whole post is.

well poyet agrees marra
 
Not sure why anyone would be surprised by this at all. In the few games he did play he was utter cackpanse. Technically he was no better than a pub player and imagine him trying to gel into Poyets passing style. No thanks.

Jesus.Seek help.

I seem to remember one special occasion when he was'nt cackpanse.SJP 0-3. I dont recall him standing out as the only crap player on the pitch,in red and white.He has his faults,and was poor in front of goal,but a pub player ?
 
Maybe you should read the posts before going all shouty?

I said Catts was a liability and not that good not that long back, and he was. He has improved loads lately. At the time when Catts was being sent off and playing shit, yeah I would have put Alfie in instead. I bet quite a few on here would have as well.

So tell me, in the last 2 or so seasons what exactly has Catts done? Injured all the time, plenty of red cards, mistakes leading to goals, yellow cards within 5 minutes ruling him out of the rest of the game, any goals or assists (bar his last one)?

Take the rose tinted geggs off man.

most of them have had spells where they have been rubbish/totally annonymous/cost us.

Cattermole has been excellent recently now, touch wood he has calmed his temper down.

I think he will always be liable to make the kind of mistakes like v hull/ villa cos he does not control the ball/have that natural touch as well as someone like Ki.

We must have a mixture of abilities for the midfield to work, there is way too much hype about catts as being the complete all round midfield god, which he never will be .....he is never gonna score many goals, play killer passes/through balls, BUT, if he plays in a midfield 3 and keeps it simple for his ability to chase/harry/inspire the team then he can be a great captain for us for years to come.

Surely a variety of Cattermole (chase and pressure) / Colback (versatile, calm on the ball, hard working)/ Seb (hard working, set piece taker) / N'Diaye (power, height, pace and can run with the ball beating his man-something the others cannot) , and also Ki if we signed him ( looks to have an eye for goal, capable of playing passes and one two's off the front man) is better than having a load of clones who jsut pass it backwards and sideways.

Pick the team to suit the game we are playing, instead of assuming Seb/Cattermole/Colback are going to play like they did late last season for a full season?
 
He had two very good games for us, the rest he did stuff where if he he was a couple inches smaller, white and had blonde or ginger hair people would have been calling him worse than shite.
 
He had two very good games for us, the rest he did stuff where if he he was a couple inches smaller, white and had blonde or ginger hair people would have been calling him worse then shite.

played great at wigan, at newcastle, v everton, did well v spurs away last game, played well v villa (one of the few who did ok that night), played well v arsenal at home-a few excellent surging runs leaving players in his wake...

Did have some sub geoff thomas shots and a few rank passes out of play, was angry at his rubbish miss away to reading which cost us, but the potential is there.
 
Jesus.Seek help.

I seem to remember one special occasion when he was'nt cackpanse.SJP 0-3. I dont recall him standing out as the only crap player on the pitch,in red and white.He has his faults,and was poor in front of goal,but a pub player ?
My view of the few games he played was of exactly that, technically very poor and hence his game was subsequently very poor as well. I never said he stood out as being the only crap player on the pitch, far from it and I never said his standard was of a pub player, just his technique. He had other qualities which would raise him far beyond a pub player. By all means disagree with my comments mate, that what a messageboard is for but please dont try and change my wording to suit your arguement.
 
Think people are being a bit harsh on him to be honest, during his time here he was no worse than most other central midfielders and actually start to show a little bit of improvement towards the end of the season

I'm not too fussed if he's sold but then I wouldn't of been if he was kept either
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Back
Top