Rocky77
Winger
The referee clearly pointed at O'Nien and motioned with his knee.
-
The first stage of the forum upgrades has now been completed but they remain in a degraded state with some features missing, normal posting/reading should now be possible.
Please read this thread for more details.
New user registrations are currently disabled.
Some other features of the forum are also currently disabled.
Luke O'Nien
- Thread starter Dodgy
- Start date
jarrowdiamond
Striker
He obviously confirmed to VAR that he gave the penalty against Alderete which is why they confirmed this name on the VAR decision.
Rocky77
Winger
No var determined Alderete won the ball therefore there was no penalty. He clearly pointed at O'Nien and motioned with his knee.
jarrowdiamond
Striker
If he gave the penalty against Luke then they would have had his name on the VAR review and not alderetes surely.
Either way neither of them fouled him.
Steve 10
Winger
Cut the Luke shit out. Its 0 Nien
Rocky77
Winger
Exactly none of them fouled him as Alderete won the ball..the ref pointed at O'Nien and motioned with his knee though. He got it wrong and Var changes it
SAFC 2012
Striker
There can’t have been many players gone from league one to championship have there?
He’s absolutely class. Not the best footballer in the world but it’s impossible not to like home and he’s certainly not showed himself up in the games he’s played.
Well maybe retiring one of city’s players aside and that howler against Newcastle but happen to anyone that
He’s absolutely class. Not the best footballer in the world but it’s impossible not to like home and he’s certainly not showed himself up in the games he’s played.
Well maybe retiring one of city’s players aside and that howler against Newcastle but happen to anyone that
HearMeRoar
Goalkeeper
Last edited:
Rocky77
Winger
I know, the ref still pointed at O'Nien and motioned with his knee. I'm not sure how many times I have to say it
Georgewhitt
Winger
You can say it as often as you like marra, but every time you do, you are clearly always wrong.
Look at the images man.
Ohnonotagain
Striker
East Stand my friend, season ticket holder but not enough points to get away tickets. XYou obviously weren't in the ground to see the 2 giant score boards with Alderetes name on for the VAR check were you.
The season we've had and after the excitement and sheer joy of the last couple of games, your first thought is to come on here and mention port vale.
Sad as fuck
And he wasn't fouled in the process.
Watch the YouTube footage of ref towards 09.
Whitburnmakem
Striker
The blokes never wrong in his eyes that’s the problem hereYou can say it as often as you like marra, but every time you do, you are clearly always wrong.
Look at the images man.
Hendon hotspurs
Midfield
No he dodnt it was a tackle. Oniens was a ridiculous back pass.Kevin Ball done the same at Sid James only he did hit the bar
The soap powder
Striker
Why are we still talking about a none event
It wasnt a penalty we move on
Rest of the game and before the none penalty he never put a foot wrong and had a great game
It wasnt a penalty we move on
Rest of the game and before the none penalty he never put a foot wrong and had a great game
Hendon hotspurs
Midfield
No he is right the ref motioned with his knee
Just some very sensitive people on here.
What an intelligent reply.
Last edited:
Rocky77
Winger
I will say it as it happened, the referee clearly pointed at O'Nien and motioned with his knee. So I'll continue to say it and be correct
You've got a cheek , fkn hell
roppa
Striker
At this level as a defender, one daft tackle, one lapse in concentration, one shirt pull, one misplaced pass, or a little bit of lack of pace will cost a goal, and will lose you points. Unfortunately o9 has all of these in his locker, and while he’s got great attitude he’s just not at the standard we need to get the club to the next level, that of established pl club imho.
My money’s on recruiting another ch, maybe lucumi or however you spell it, and o9 moving further down the pecking order, then it’ll be up to him if he stays, maybe developing into a coaching role, or goes for regular minutes to a lower tier club. However he ends up, he’s been a great servant to the club, who definitely helped us through all the league one shite and has helped lay the foundations for a decent future.
My money’s on recruiting another ch, maybe lucumi or however you spell it, and o9 moving further down the pecking order, then it’ll be up to him if he stays, maybe developing into a coaching role, or goes for regular minutes to a lower tier club. However he ends up, he’s been a great servant to the club, who definitely helped us through all the league one shite and has helped lay the foundations for a decent future.
To be fair to him he was only replying to a question that was asked which he was spot on. He was comparing them with the other mistakes of so called class playersThey dont affect my team. Think you just need to calm down a bit
I thought as it happened he gave it against o9 as from his position all he could see was him sliding in at the same time the spurs lad stood on alderete's foot causing him to fall over. He couldn't see the actual foul and gave it because of the slide by o9 which to me makes it he guessed and got it wrong and var told him.I will say it as it happened, the referee clearly pointed at O'Nien and motioned with his knee. So I'll continue to say it and be correct
You've got a cheek , fkn hell
Last edited:
KGC83
Striker
So you are using a dodgy back pass where he was clearly shoved to back your argument up about him not being good enough and you’ve got the cheek to say what an intelligent reply?
The best centre backs in the world make mistakes at times. Onien has been outstanding when called upon this season. If you think otherwise you’ve clearly got an agenda against the lad.
Falconhoof
Striker
HOW DARE YOU COME ON HERE WITH YOUR COMMON SENSE APPROACH!
