• The forums will be unavailable for a few hours on Saturday 6th June, when they do return they will initially be in a degraded state with some features missing, but normal posting/reading will be possible. The main website will not be affected by these updates.
    New user registrations are currently disabled.
    Some other features of the forum are also currently disabled.

Any changes for the 5th Test


Potts for Atkinson
Gay/Mckenzie for Duckett
Bashir for Jacks (id prefer any other spinner if we had picked one)
 
Potts for Atkinson
Gay/Mckenzie for Duckett
Bashir for Jacks (id prefer any other spinner if we had picked one)
If you’re prepared to add a batter who isn’t in the squad, why not a spinner? They’re just as easy to put on an aeroplane!
 
Atkinson will be out so Potts deserves a game. I’d also play Bashir. I think it’s fair and reasonable to use the squad, the Aussies are far from full strength and Sydney whatever anyone says is a dead rubber. Of course you want to win and you could argue careers are on the line, but I don’t think there’s anything we can learn about the players we have they are known forces now !
 
Dead rubber is a tennis term from the now obsolete Davis cup format, for matches that were played under the different rules to the live rubber matches and that no one cared about at all. It has crept fairy fairly recently into cricket. I don’t think it’s appropriate to the tradition of test cricket.

The Sydney test will be played to exactly the same rules and count in exactly the same way. as the other four. It will be included when it comes to the cumulative numbers in England Australia win loss stats. Without an asterisk. It will count exactly the same as the other four when it comes to the individual batting and bowling averages. It will count exactly the same as the other four when they print the series results score line in the history books. It will count exactly the same as the other four, for those that care about such things, when it comes to having 12 WTC points at stake.

It is obviously true that once a series winner is settled there is a tendency by the winning side to take the foot off the gas. Although one of the things that marks the recent Australians is that they still win. But it has never been true that the test matches that happen after a series is settled have any formal reduced value. I doubt if even the most nerdy former player could tell you how many of their runs or wickets were achieved in matches where a series was alive and how many weren’t. A test match is a test match is a test match. And a test match isn’t a rubber.
 
Last edited:
Should definitely play.Been in a lot of squads but doesn’t get a game although fit.If he was injury prone he would walk into the team!
 
Back
Top