Liam Rosenior

[Safc1987]

Have i missed something has he got the job?

 

[Niz]

And Beale

Kind of proves my point, we don't know untill they are in the building.

 

[Rocky77]

He wanted players experienced players and was denied ?

And he knew exactly what the job entailed when he took it. He's a yes man as much as anyone.

 

[Clavas]

Or see how he does

Mine are bigger

"Seeing how he does" went well with Mr Beale

You could hire absolutely anyone with a "see how he/she does" philosophy
Entire recruitment companies could be closed down as they won't be needed - just see how they do

 

[Safc98]

Why wouldn’t you count league one achievements when we were a league one club at the time?

Because I’m not a fan of the copy and paste CV approach to appointing managers. Colchester in 2006 is not comparable to Sunderland in 2019

 

[AyeAyeAye]

From what I’ve seen of his Hull sides yeah I’d be alright with him. The consensus was he was harshly sacked and had Hull moving in the right direction.

Who do you want?

But he has less, as in zero, achievements. As I’ve said previously I’d like Maric.

 

[rentaghost]

"Seeing how he does" went well with Mr Beale

You could hire absolutely anyone with a "see how he/she does" philosophy
Entire recruitment companies could be closed down as they won't be needed - just see how they do

It do well with Mowbray and Denis Smith etc. What's the choice?

 

[Boris Bear]

It will be embarrassing if it’s him

 

[Rocky77]

"Seeing how he does" went well with Mr Beale

You could hire absolutely anyone with a "see how he/she does" philosophy
Entire recruitment companies could be closed down as they won't be needed - just see how they do

It went well with Mowbray, who wasn't a popular appointment.

I'm not really in favour of Rosenior but the way in which he is being written off is way over the top

 

[Safc98]

As I’ve said previously I’d like Maric.

As would I but this is sort of an own goal as he’s got no achievements and no experience. Kind of the point. It’s why I’m not that interested in a CV and “past achievements”

 

[Rocky77]

It will be embarrassing if it’s him

For who?
Will you be embarrassed? I know I won't.

 

[Boris Bear]

For who?
Will you be embarrassed? I know I won't.

You have low standards

 

[samsafc]

Could do worse but would hardly be an inspiring appointment.

 

[scott934]

But he has less, as in zero, achievements. As I’ve said previously I’d like Maric.

I agree with you in terms of Maric, he'd be my first choice. But you're arguing against yourself with this post.

 

[Di Canios Knees]

Because I’m not a fan of the copy and paste CV approach to appointing managers. Colchester in 2006 is not comparable to Sunderland in 2019

What about Bolton in 2017? I personally didn’t want him or think he would do a good job like most people and we were right but you can’t just ignore his achievements at that level because the club was “bigger” than the level it found itself at.

 

[Rocky77]

You have low standards

So you're embarrassed? How will you face your embarrassment?

 

[Safc98]

What about Bolton in 2017? I personally didn’t want him or think he would do a good job like most people and we were right but you can’t just ignore his achievements at that level because the club was “bigger” than the level it found itself at.

You can because if we’d gone up with Parkinson we’d have no potential to go any further under him

 

[Di Canios Knees]

Kind of proves my point, we don't know untill they are in the building.

For me appointing Rosenior would just be when you eat the strawberry ones in the Quality Street because all the good ones have gone and you haven’t got any other choice and can’t be arsed to go out and buy anything, just my opinion like

 

[cluffy]

Just listened to the Second Tier podcast. They’ve got Rosenior at number one in the available managers. Full of praise for him.

You must be logged on to see media items

 

[andysafc24]

It went well with Mowbray, who wasn't a popular appointment.

I'm not really in favour of Rosenior but the way in which he is being written off is way over the top

No it is not OTT.
People are sick of these ambitious appointments.
When TM was originally sacked we were led to believe it was because they wanted to move forward.
It has been backwards steps ever since.