• The first stage of the forum upgrades has now been completed but they remain in a degraded state and are still being worked on. Normal posting/reading should now be possible.
    Please read this thread for more details.
    New user registrations are currently disabled.

The ref (see PGMOL thread)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Mowgli said:
Are you saying giving that as a free kick is acceptable?
Click to expand...

It's a mistake like all the others you have posted. Why do you think it keeps happening for? It's either every ref in the world ever has been absolutely shite or the job is tougher than you think. Stop focusing on individual decisions and lot at the wider picture. Why does every ref in the world continue to get individual decisions wrong?
 

Roker-73 said:
Referees should be forced to make a statement after every game to the clubs and fans. Put the little weasels under the spotlight in front of the people who’s weekend they spoil

Additionally every refereeing performance should be assessed in minute detail each week by an independent panel. Too many shit ratings and you should be struck off
Click to expand...
I am sure sacking refs for bad ratings, will really encourage new refs to take up game and improve things great idea.
 
Voice of fair play said:
I am sure sacking refs for bad ratings, will really encourage new refs to take up game and improve things great idea.
Click to expand...
I don’t give a fuck

Sacking doctors for making errors probably doesn’t encourage other doctors. Does that matter?

Also, according to you we don’t need to “improve things” anyway. The current refs are doing a sterling job
 
Last edited:
redandwhiterob said:
It's a mistake like all the others you have posted. Why do you think it keeps happening for? It's either every ref in the world ever has been absolutely shite or the job is tougher than you think. Stop focusing on individual decisions and lot at the wider picture. Why does every ref in the world continue to get individual decisions wrong?
Click to expand...
Some mistakes you accept when they obviously can't see or it's a clip at speed between loads of legs.

This is an unobstructed view from less than 10 yards away.

No excuse whatsoever
 
Mowgli said:
Some mistakes you accept when they obviously can't see or it's a clip at speed between loads of legs.

This is an unobstructed view from less than 10 yards away.

No excuse whatsoever
Click to expand...

Again how many times have you said that? Again that's just in the games you have watched. If these things keep happening what does it tell you? You can't just focus on individual decisions, have a look at the wider picture
 
Voice of fair play said:
I am sure sacking refs for bad ratings, will really encourage new refs to take up game and improve things great idea.
Click to expand...
Sacking refs or demoting them for being incompetent is fair though like any other job.

What annoys me is that referees are not allowed to be criticised. Everytime they make a mistake here you are.

You come across as arrogant and like you are better than every one else. It’s hard for you to see anyone’s opinion.

You are making out like cricketers don’t cheat plenty do I watch both sports I also played both sports.

Just maybe If you respect other peoples point of view you might have better discussions on here.
 
redandwhiterob said:
Again how many times have you said that? Again that's just in the games you have watched. If these things keep happening what does it tell you? You can't just focus on individual decisions, have a look at the wider picture
Click to expand...
I'm still waiting for you to tell me what foul he has seen from 5 yards away.

What has he seen to give it? Or has he invented a foul?

It's a simple question really. I'm asking specifically about this one foul.
 
Missplaced Childhood said:
I have no answer why he carded Neil and not Crooks or even why he ignored multiple blatent shirt pulls by Boro players but the second Roberts did one he was carded, i am however of the opinion he was massively out of his depth and grossly incompetent as the other option is to think he was corrupt which i dont want to believe.
Click to expand...
If by the Crooks one you mean the shirt pull where he played advantage and then didn’t card when play stopped, that one is because you’re no longer allowed to go back and card for stopping a promising attack if you play advantage. Why they’ve decided that I haven’t a clue but it means the decision was correct. One of the few. He had a poor game. But not for that one.
 
Mowgli said:
I'm still waiting for you to tell me what foul he has seen from 5 yards away.

What has he seen to give it? Or has he invented a foul?

It's a simple question really. I'm asking specifically about this one foul.
Click to expand...

Again you keep trying to pin me down on individual decisions. You haven't got the intelligence to take a step back and get into a wider discussion. He's obviously just made a fuck up given his view at full speed from one angle.
 
Mowgli said:
Are you trying to defend that decision like Rob will?
Click to expand...
No I am saying just becuase one bad mistake is made, does not mean loads of good ones are not made in other games.

Just like a forward missing a easy chance does not mean great goals are scored in others.

Putting a link up of a agreed bad error, does prove fuck all.
 
Fleagle said:
If by the Crooks one you mean the shirt pull where he played advantage and then didn’t card when play stopped, that one is because you’re no longer allowed to go back and card for stopping a promising attack if you play advantage. Why they’ve decided that I haven’t a clue but it means the decision was correct. One of the few. He had a poor game. But not for that one.
Click to expand...
No mate im on about Crooks shouting fuck off at the ref from about 2-3 yards away.
 
Mission said:
There wouldn’t be one single Sunderland fan complaining about the ref had it been a Boro player receiving a second yellow for dissent - not one. FACT. In fact Dan Neil was extremely fortunate to be still on the field for the first offence which would very often be a straight red for endangering an opponent. The fact it didn’t make full contact is irrelevant. For anyone who doesn’t know the rules of football see below
You must be logged on to see external links
Click to expand...
Answer honestly. Are you fuming if its a Boro man getting sent off in the same circumstances? (the apparent 'dissent')
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top