India v England series

[GuestServices]

Bess will lose us this game

 

[Scunny Dan]

theres just no consistency, how can they give teh bairstow one out n not that

Because the Umpires are human, not ball tracking robots. If you don't like Umps Call on DRS, thats fair enough. But its not the Umpires on the fields fault.

 

[The Rat]

Because the Umpires are human, not ball tracking robots. If you don't like Umps Call on DRS, thats fair enough. But its not the Umpires on the fields fault.

Shock that the decision on the field goes for india as per

 

[rentaghost]

theres just no consistency, how can they give teh bairstow one out n not that

Or the rohit one that was umpired call on two counts. Because they are human

 

[mackembhoy]

theres just no consistency, how can they give teh bairstow one out n not that

They get one view at the end of the day.

I thought the Bairstow one was missing the stumps on first viewing. But it was quite a skiddy ball.

I thought on my second viewing it's clipping.

But yes the pant one was definitely closer. But the spinners tend to get more bounce on these pitches.

 

[Scunny Dan]

Shock that the decision on the field goes for india as per

Its been fairly even this test. Stokes got an LBW with a double umps call. I don't think your criticism is warranted.

 

[The Rat]

Its been fairly even this test. Stokes got an LBW with a double umps call. I don't think your criticism is warranted.

I do, Bairstows was avery poor decision as was Pants

 

[Scunny Dan]

I do, Bairstows was avery poor decision as was Pants

Agree to disagree then.

 

[mackembhoy]

Completely agree with I think Karthik here.

I know leach isn't as good as against lefties. But he's your number 1 spinner here.

We also saw him trap pant on the crease and on another day get the decision

 

[rentaghost]

Shock that the decision on the field goes for india as per

Statistics were shown that umpires call decisions in this series have been almost identical with the likes of Kohli band Rohit twice being given out that way. You are paranoid.

 

[scotch]

Suspect we wont see Bess bowl again in this innings, Tuffers saying be needs a longer run up

 

[GuestServices]

Suspect we wont see Bess bowl again in this innings, Tuffers saying be needs a longer run up

going out of the stadium ??

 

[Sea to Shining Sea]

Umpires call needs to be reviewed. Can’t have a ball hitting the stumps flush and being given not out. If more than 2/3 of the ball is hitting the stumps it should be given out. The ones that clip the stumps could be umpires call to allow for any discrepancies in the technology but that last Pant DRS decision just makes a mockery of the decision.

The umpires call was just simply wrong and then the technology has somehow backed up a very incorrect decision. Not the on field umpires fault as they’re human but haway

 

[FatDrummer]

Well said Swann!

 

[Sea to Shining Sea]

Well said Swann!

It’s a rarity that he’s talking sense but he is this time. Enough of the ball is hitting there for the element of doubt to be taken out of it. It’s hitting flush, not a clip the bails type ball

 

[Scunny Dan]

That bloody siren is pathetic.

 

[SAFC11]

A spinner should never be overstepping by that much

 

[Captain Slackbladder]

Get Jimmy on ffs....

 

[The Rat]

Statistics were shown that umpires call decisions in this series have been almost identical with the likes of Kohli band Rohit twice being given out that way. You are paranoid.

With all due respect mate, you said there was nothing to see with the third umpires

the bairstow and pant ones were poor decisions, fine to disagree

 

[dixonsafc]

Can't believe I missed the no ball siren while I was at the bog.

Gutted.