Gary madine



He's a good player but is he the type of signing we need? (I'm not talking about on the pitch) He's a very divisive character, got plenty of personal problems as evidenced by previous criminal convictions including a custodial sentence. Would imagine we need somebody who can come in and get the whole fan base behind him instantly and thrive off the back of that support. Is he going to be that type? That's not even taking into account his NUFC allegiance and comments on social media regarding SAFC from a number of years ago.
He's a good player but is he the type of signing we need? (I'm not talking about on the pitch) He's a very divisive character, got plenty of personal problems as evidenced by previous criminal convictions including a custodial sentence. Would imagine we need somebody who can come in and get the whole fan base behind him instantly and thrive off the back of that support. Is he going to be that type? That's not even taking into account his NUFC allegiance and comments on social media regarding SAFC from a number of years ago.

In top of that, with Warnock now gone he may well find himself back in favour at Cardiff.
 
He’s much better than anything we’ve got but I’m not sure being back up here permanently will do him or us any favours.
 

Back
Top