Our Most Valuable Players - if we sold.

[jcrossan]

Sort of depressing imagining what we might get if we had to sell our players. Gives you an idea of the paucity of the talent - too many foreign, unproven players or older ones who are past their best. Can'y see any one of them going for as much as ten million.

Top four for me would be.

Cattermole. About 7-8 million.
Johnson. 6-8 million.
Defoe (mainly cos of his age ) $6 mill.
Pants. $5 mill.

Some team might take a flyer still on Wickham and some newly promoted team might look at Fletcher and SEB.

After that its pretty thin.

 

[PhilSAFC]

Be worth more in pounds I reckon

 

[Tobin7]

I reckon Pants is two or three world class performances from the 7.5-8m mark.

 

[johnson]

I reckon Pants is two or three world class performances from the 7.5-8m mark.

massive shout

 

[Hatful Of Hollow]

Johnson by a mile

 

[johnson]

Sort of depressing imagining what we might get if we had to sell our players. Gives you an idea of the paucity of the talent - too many foreign, unproven players or older ones who are past their best. Can'y see any one of them going for as much as ten million.

Top four for me would be.

Cattermole. About 7-8 million.
Johnson. 6-8 million.
Defoe (mainly cos of his age ) $6 mill.
Pants. $5 mill.

Some team might take a flyer still on Wickham and some newly promoted team might look at Fletcher and SEB.

After that its pretty thin.

Wickham would get a good fee, over 6 million

 

[jcrossan]

Be worth more in pounds I reckon

Can't afford a keyboard with it on..

 

[James]

£8m for Cattermole? Johnson would fetch about £8-10m. The rest are fairly worthless, Pants about £5m, Defoe about £3m. Could probably get about £4m for Seb.

Depends really, you're only worth what others are willing to pay up. Promoted teams are generally the idiots in this case.

 

[tom92]

Some daft **** (probably Bruce)will pay £5m for fletch in the summer imo

 

[Ashley In!!]

Rodwell still.

 

[Lord Alfred]

If we were a shop we'd be based at the bottom of Hylton Rd.

 

[jamieboy]

who the fuck is gonn pay 8 million for lee cattermole..... fuckin behave man 3 at most

 

[parsonjohn1985]

Johnson
Cattermole
Rodwell
Fletcher
Wickham
Giaccherini

Could all go for decent money. Just because people in sunderland see them every week doesn't mean that their reputation isn't reasonable elsewhere.

 

[viccarlton]

Our whole squad is probably only worth £ XXXX, what we would actually get for them is considerably less.

 

[James]

Johnson
Cattermole
Rodwell
Fletcher
Wickham
Giaccherini

Could all go for decent money. Just because people in sunderland see them every week doesn't mean that their reputation isn't reasonable elsewhere.

Cattermole has a shit reputation nationally, he's injury prone and seen as a liability, I don't think he'd go for much. You're probably right about the others, although I think the chances of shifting Giacc for a decent fee have just gone out of the window.

 

[Bishop Mackem]

Buckley and bridcutt. Half a loaf of bread and a tin of beans between them.

 

[jcrossan]

Johnson
Cattermole
Rodwell
Fletcher
Wickham
Giaccherini

Could all go for decent money. Just because people in sunderland see them every week doesn't mean that their reputation isn't reasonable elsewhere.

Can't see anyone paying much for Rodwell unless he starts performing regularly. He was thought injury prone before we took him and any premier league team is going to think long and hard before offering a contract to a player who can't keep fit and uninjured.

 

[PaulG]

All that matters is that we get more than we paid for them.

 

[Mr Chips]

We would get more selling the big screens in the stadium than we would from any players.

 

[Smartie]

Very sobering concidering the millions invested over the years. Something's not right.