Best and worst........

[Kid Galahad]

.......central midfielder ever to play for us (min 10 apps)in your era ?

Best - Don Hutchison
Worst - Steve Berry (would have been Tommy Miller if he'd played for us )

[Aberdeen Angus]

In theory Hutchison but he spent a lot of time out right and not a lot of time in the centre so I'll say

Best in the top flight: Schwarz
Worst in the top flight: Tommy Miller

Best in 2nd flight: Clark (unfortunately)
Worst in 2nd flight: Martin Gray

Contradicted myself a bit with Schwarz given that he was pushed out left a lot

[Flan]

Best- Schwarz
Worst- Miller (would have been too easy to pick a Gerry Harrison type but for the amount of games he got, Miller was shit).

[ck1.gsy]

Originally Posted by Flan

Best- Schwarz
Worst- Miller

No brainer really...although Hutch does come a close second to Schwarz.

[Kid Galahad]

Originally Posted by ck1.gsy

No brainer really...although Hutch does come a close second to Schwarz.

Went for Hutch for his goal threat and pace around the park,Stef was class though,Alex Rae would be up there aswell.
.

[godspeed]

Originally Posted by Flan

Best- Schwarz
Worst- Miller (would have been too easy to pick a Gerry Harrison type but for the amount of games he got, Miller was shit).

Miller was Bobby Charlton when compared to Shaun Cunnington.

He received dog's abuse from the Main Stand Paddock when coming to take a throw once, turned round and held his hands up in a show of empathy with the fans.

He was truly shite, and he knew it.

[Rotherham red'n'white]

Originally Posted by Kid Galahad

.......central midfielder ever to play for us (min 10 apps)in your era ?

Best - Don Hutchison
Worst - Steve Berry (would have been Tommy Miller if he'd played for us )

Steve Berry - horrible memories. Not seen a worse top flight midfield player at Sunderland since. Makes Tommy Miller look like Pele by comparison.

[Parkmaverick]

Best Mike Buckley or Bracewell

Worst- there was a kid who played at the same time as Steve Berry and I can't remember his name.

[Masterplan]

Worst - Steve Doyle
Best - Stefan Schwarz

[Kid Galahad]

Originally Posted by Parkmaverick

Best Mike Buckley or Bracewell

Worst- there was a kid who played at the same time as Steve Berry and I can't remember his name.

Peter Daniel was there at the same time,he was shite,but hardly a kid.