Best ever PL goalkeeper

[KEV_SAFC_FTM]

There have been some fantastic goalkeepers in the PL over the years, but who would you say was the best all-round?

Schmeichel
Given
Martyn
Freidel
James
Seaman
Hart
Reina
Cech

For me, Schmeichel had the lot. He wasnt just a fantastic shot-stopper, he would come and take crosses and generally command his box. Most importantly you would rarely see a mistake by him.

[Geronimo]

James wouldn't make any list of mine.

[THE_MAINSTAND_BAND]

Schmeical then Seaman.

[hullmackem]

Schmeichel, end of thread.

[naughtynose]

Originally Posted by KEV_SAFC_FTM

There have been some fantastic goalkeepers in the PL over the years, but who would you say was the best all-round?

Schmeichel
Given
Martyn
Freidel
James
Seaman
Hart
Reina
Cech

For me, Schmeichel had the lot. He wasnt just a fantastic shot-stopper, he would come and take crosses and generally command his box. Most importantly you would rarely see a mistake by him.

There you go. Most of the others arent fit to lace his boots, or wear his gloves

[SR6 MACKEM]

nee van der saar?

[KEV_SAFC_FTM]

Originally Posted by Geronimo

James wouldn't make any list of mine.

Just put him in because of his longetivity of playing in the PL at a high level. On his day, he could make saves no-one else could.... and in the same breath could produce an absolute howler

[Jambezz]

[KEV_SAFC_FTM]

Originally Posted by SR6 MACKEM

nee van der saar?

or Paul Robinson. Just made a quick list of the top of my head

[abbs]

only play in goal cos they are to shit to play out!