Premier League Decision Table

[The Situation]

http://www.debatabledecisions.com/

Before today, Stoke have benefited from 15 incorrect decisions this season, almost double the next nearest (Bolton on 8) and our lovely neighbours Newcastle on 7.

It's only fair to add on the 2 they've got today from Wolves when Woodgate should have been sent off and they scored from a free kick that never should have been.

Benefiting 17 times already this season from wrong decisions, and to think Pulis has the cheek to complain about referees

We've had 5 for us, and 5 against us.

Interesting to note Arsenal and Everton are on -5, and WBA on -4.

Just goes to show that referee's poor decisions are costing clubs lots of points and millions of pounds in the process, yet they get away with it time and time again.

[SuperKevin]

According to Football Focus, if we had scored every time we have hit the post this season, we would be level on points with Manchester City.

Downing has hit the post 3 times.

[Aphrodite]

If you've had 5 for and 5 against how has it cost you anything?

I think it's unrealistic to expect officials to get everything correct- we don't expect it of players after all.

Also, a lot of the 'decisions' made on that site, in retrospect are split or fairly dubious.

[The Situation]

Originally Posted by Aphrodite

If you've had 5 for and 5 against how has it cost you anything?

Eh, it hasn't.

[Lewberry pie]

funny that I new stoke, mags, bolton would be top, stoke remind me of solicitors that get theives off on a technicality then get them compensation, using the rules against the spirit in which they were written.

I'm aware we are not a team of nuns.

[MackemX]

only 2 points between us and Mags in the Real Premier League Table!

http://www.debatabledecisions.com/tables

The Real Premier League Table
Team 		P 	W 	D 	L 	F 	A 	GD 	PTS
Man Utd 	15 	14 	0 	1 	34 	13 	21 	42
Man City 	15 	12 	3 	0 	52 	14 	38 	39
Chelsea 	15 	11 	1 	3 	35 	17 	18 	34
Arsenal 	15 	10 	3 	2 	34 	20 	14 	33
Spurs 		14 	9 	3 	2 	28 	18 	10 	30
Liverpool 	15 	7 	6 	2 	20 	12 	8 	27
Norwich 	15 	5 	5 	5 	24 	28 	-4 	20
Newcastle 	15 	5 	4 	6 	21 	23 	-2 	19
SAFC 		15 	4 	5 	6 	19 	17 	2 	17
Swansea 	15 	4 	5 	6 	17 	22 	-5 	17
Everton 	14 	4 	4 	6 	18 	18 	0 	16
A Villa 	15 	3 	7 	5 	16 	20 	-4 	16
Wolves 		15 	4 	3 	8 	18 	30 	-12 	15
Fulham 		15 	2 	8 	5 	17 	18 	-1 	14
W.B.A. 		15 	3 	4 	8 	19 	24 	-5 	13
Wigan 		15 	3 	3 	9 	14 	28 	-14 	12
Blackburn 	15 	2 	5 	8 	22 	34 	-12 	11
Stoke 		15 	2 	5 	8 	16 	28 	-12 	11
Q.P.R. 		15 	2 	5 	8 	14 	29 	-15 	11
Bolton 		15 	3 	0 	12 	19 	39 	-2 	9

[Paxton]

We normally get shit awful luck from refs

[safcforever]

Originally Posted by Aphrodite

If you've had 5 for and 5 against how has it cost you anything?

I think it's unrealistic to expect officials to get everything correct- we don't expect it of players after all.

Also, a lot of the 'decisions' made on that site, in retrospect are split or fairly dubious.

By awarding other teams penalties/free kicks/allowing 11 men to remain on the pitch/handball etc has helped teams gain wins/draws. This then gives them undeserved points.
Then the league places teams with the most points gained (fairly or not) in order. So any team that has un-fairly gained say 5 points this season then has a better chance of finishing higher up the league than a team who hasn't.


Hope that has cleared it up for you.

[flusheding]

Originally Posted by safcforever

By awarding other teams penalties/free kicks/allowing 11 men to remain on the pitch/handball etc has helped teams gain wins/draws. This then gives them undeserved points.
Then the league places teams with the most points gained (fairly or not) in order. So any team that has un-fairly gained say 5 points this season then has a better chance of finishing higher up the league than a team who hasn't.

Hope that has cleared it up for you.

But 5 points for and against, affecting one team means they are equal and back to 0 :P

[Hetzkes Ballet Teacher]

Originally Posted by MackemX

only 2 points between us and Mags in the Real Premier League Table!

http://www.debatabledecisions.com/tables

The Real Premier League Table
Team 		P 	W 	D 	L 	F 	A 	GD 	PTS
Man Utd 	15 	14 	0 	1 	34 	13 	21 	42
Man City 	15 	12 	3 	0 	52 	14 	38 	39
Chelsea 	15 	11 	1 	3 	35 	17 	18 	34
Arsenal 	15 	10 	3 	2 	34 	20 	14 	33
Spurs 		14 	9 	3 	2 	28 	18 	10 	30
Liverpool 	15 	7 	6 	2 	20 	12 	8 	27
Norwich 	15 	5 	5 	5 	24 	28 	-4 	20
Newcastle 	15 	5 	4 	6 	21 	23 	-2 	19
SAFC 		15 	4 	5 	6 	19 	17 	2 	17
Swansea 	15 	4 	5 	6 	17 	22 	-5 	17
Everton 	14 	4 	4 	6 	18 	18 	0 	16
A Villa 	15 	3 	7 	5 	16 	20 	-4 	16
Wolves 		15 	4 	3 	8 	18 	30 	-12 	15
Fulham 		15 	2 	8 	5 	17 	18 	-1 	14
W.B.A. 		15 	3 	4 	8 	19 	24 	-5 	13
Wigan 		15 	3 	3 	9 	14 	28 	-14 	12
Blackburn 	15 	2 	5 	8 	22 	34 	-12 	11
Stoke 		15 	2 	5 	8 	16 	28 	-12 	11
Q.P.R. 		15 	2 	5 	8 	14 	29 	-15 	11
Bolton 		15 	3 	0 	12 	19 	39 	-2 	9

Bruce IN!