Argentinian people

[Jake51]

Originally Posted by Andy.SAFC

Fuck off

Maybe if Brown or O'Shea were playing at full back as he's better than Turner, Ferdinand and Bramble, but he's not a patch on either of those at centre back. One look at their career records tells you that.

Career records tell you nothing. I'd have thought you'd learnt that lesson after the Muntari fiasco. If you judge players on their career records, especially when you're also undoubtedly looking through rose tinted specs, then it's no surprise your judgement is so awfully skewed. I still cannot believe Wes fucking Brown is rated so highly on here.

[garydon]

Originally Posted by Jake51

Career records tell you nothing. I'd have thought you'd learnt that lesson after the Muntari fiasco. If you judge players on their career records, especially when you're also undoubtedly looking through rose tinted specs, then it's no surprise your judgement is so awfully skewed. I still cannot believe Wes fucking Brown is rated so highly on here.

Using your words, he would walk into your team. So would Ferdinand, and he's poor.

[andymc]

Originally Posted by Jake51

Career records tell you nothing. I'd have thought you'd learnt that lesson after the Muntari fiasco. If you judge players on their career records, especially when you're also undoubtedly looking through rose tinted specs, then it's no surprise your judgement is so awfully skewed. I still cannot believe Wes fucking Brown is rated so highly on here.

Totally agree, Wes Brown has only won numerous trophies and played in Man Utd's champions league final team in 2008. He's shite like

[Andy.SAFC]

Originally Posted by Jake51

Career records tell you nothing. I'd have thought you'd learnt that lesson after the Muntari fiasco. If you judge players on their career records, especially when you're also undoubtedly looking through rose tinted specs, then it's no surprise your judgement is so awfully skewed. I still cannot believe Wes fucking Brown is rated so highly on here.

So using that logic then, you've based your opinion on fuck all since O'Shea and Brown have not played for us yet.

They are both class acts, they have 600 games for the best team in the country between them ffs. Sideshow Bob has had one decent season in the Prem, and a season where he was completely shite too.

[Jake51]

Originally Posted by andymc

Totally agree, Wes Brown has only won numerous trophies and played in Man Utd's champions league final team in 2008. He's shite like

Aye and here's the honours list of another top defender..

Premier League (2): 1995–96, 1996–97
FA Cup (2): 1995–96, 1998–99
FA Community Shield (2): 1994, 1996
UEFA Champions League (1): 1998–99

.. once you've figured out who I'd hope you'd see how flawed that logic is.
Ironically enough, he played the exact same role Brown has for the past decade.

[j.w]

Now 'Pards' is getting the Carroll money and the Enrique money Collo won't be needed

Can we have him, pretty please help your poor neighbours out

[Dumas]

People on this Valencia fan forum seem to have no better clue, but one claiming fans of other teams heard it on the radio

[Jake51]

Originally Posted by Andy.SAFC

So using that logic then, you've based your opinion on fuck all since O'Shea and Brown have not played for us yet.

They are both class acts, they have 600 games for the best team in the country between them ffs. Sideshow Bob has had one decent season in the Prem, and a season where he was completely shite too.

And this is what the ignorant football fan, yourself included, bases their opinions of him on. Everyone just seemed to mark him down as shite due to a troubled first season (where in all fairness to the lad, he played in front of Geremi, Alan Smith and Nicky Butt and alongside players like Cacapa) and are unwilling to alter their opinion. If you'd watched him last season, he was man of the match at your place so you've no excuse not to have paid attention, you'd realise he's so much more than that.

As for Brown, I'm extremely confident I'll be able to come back in a years time and very smugly say "I told you so."

Originally Posted by Jake51

Geremi, Alan Smith and Nicky Butt

Actually, you might want to check out their career records too. I'm sure all three's look fairly decent pre-Newcastle. Players from top 4 clubs, on the way down, looking for one last payday rarely work; it's a very slippery slope.

[j.w]

Originally Posted by Jake51

And this is what the ignorant football fan, yourself included, bases their opinions of him on. Everyone just seemed to mark him down as shite due to a troubled first season (where in all fairness to the lad, he played in front of Geremi, Alan Smith and Nicky Butt and alongside players like Cacapa) and are unwilling to alter their opinion. If you'd watched him last season, he was man of the match at your place so you've no excuse not to have paid attention, you'd realise he's so much more than that.

As for Brown, I'm extremely confident I'll be able to come back in a years time and very smugly say "I told you so."



Actually, you might want to check out their career records too. I'm sure all three's look fairly decent pre-Newcastle. Players from top 4 clubs, on the way down, looking for one last payday rarely work; it's a very slippery slope.

I could have been man of the match at our place

Luckily Gyans knee was

[andymc]

Originally Posted by Jake51

Aye and here's the honours list of another top defender..

Premier League (2): 1995–96, 1996–97
FA Cup (2): 1995–96, 1998–99
FA Community Shield (2): 1994, 1996
UEFA Champions League (1): 1998–99

.. once you've figured out who I'd hope you'd see how flawed that logic is.
Ironically enough, he played the exact same role Brown has for the past decade.

So your saying a very experienced defender who has played hundreds of games for the best team in Premier League history, even the best club in English history with 19 titles to their name is shite. Whilst a defender who had a terrible season then a good one in a shite league then a decent one in a team that over achieved is better?

Alright then. I think it's about time you fucked off and stopped boring people.