MON's transfer dealings

[SuperKev]

P.S. Likely SEB but couldn't see it.

06/07
Stiliyan Petrov........£6.5m
Didier Agathe........Signed
Chris Sutton........Free
John Carew Lyon........Swap
Ashley Young........£9.65m
Shaun Maloney........£1m
Nigel Reo-Coker........£7.5m
Total: £24.65m

07/08

Marlon Harewood........£4m
Zat Knight........£3.5m
Moustapha Salifou........Nominal
Wayne Routledge........£1.25m
Total: £8.75m

08/09

Curtis Davies........£8m
Steven Sidwell........£5m
Brad Friedel........£2m
Brad Guzan........£600K
Nicky Shorey........Signed
Luke Young........£5m
Carlos Cuellar........£7.8m
James Milner........Signed * think it was £12m
Emile Heskey........£3.5m
Total: £31.9m * + £12m

09/10
Stewart Downing........£12m
Fabian Delph........Signed
Habib Beye........Signed
Stephen Warnock........Signed
James Collins........£5m
Richard Dunne........£5m
Total: £22,000,000 + Delph, Beye and Warnock

During this time he clawed back £32.6 mill and since then the club have clawed back an extra £63 mill from the sales of Milner, Downing and Young.

All in all some cracking buys, a few dodgies (Davies and Cuellar in particular) and a bad sale (Cahill for 5 mill).

[Mr Redknapp]

Originally Posted by SuperKev

06/07
Stiliyan Petrov........£6.5m
Didier Agathe........Signed
Chris Sutton........Free
John Carew Lyon........Swap
Ashley Young........£9.65m
Shaun Maloney........£1m
Nigel Reo-Coker........£7.5m
Total: £24.65m

07/08

Marlon Harewood........£4m
Zat Knight........£3.5m
Moustapha Salifou........Nominal
Wayne Routledge........£1.25m
Total: £8.75m

08/09

Curtis Davies........£8m
Steven Sidwell........£5m
Brad Friedel........£2m
Brad Guzan........£600K
Nicky Shorey........Signed
Luke Young........£5m
Carlos Cuellar........£7.8m
James Milner........Signed * think it was £12m
Emile Heskey........£3.5m
Total: £31.9m * + £12m

09/10
Stewart Downing........£12m
Fabian Delph........Signed
Habib Beye........Signed
Stephen Warnock........Signed
James Collins........£5m
Richard Dunne........£5m
Total: £22,000,000 + Delph, Beye and Warnock

During this time he clawed back £32.6 mill and since then the club have clawed back an extra £63 mill from the sales of Milner, Downing and Young.

All in all some cracking buys, a few dodgies (Davies and Cuellar in particular) and a bad sale (Cahill for 5 mill).

Cueller was excellent under O'Neill.

[Tony_Montana1981]

Originally Posted by SuperKev

John Carew Lyon........Swap
Ashley Young........£9.65m
Brad Friedel........£2m
James Milner........Signed * think it was £12m
Emile Heskey........£3.5m
Stewart Downing........£12m
Stephen Warnock........Signed

Good signings

Originally Posted by SuperKev

Stiliyan Petrov........£6.5m
Nigel Reo-Coker........£7.5m
Marlon Harewood........£4m
Curtis Davies........£8m
Steven Sidwell........£5m
James Collins........£5m

Bad signings.

The others - meh

[Tommasi]

Davies does stick out but the fact is all managers sign shite, Ferguson definitely has, so has Mourinho, Cloughie, etc-you cant get it right 100% of the time.

[jsdftm04]

Originally Posted by SuperKev

P.S. Likely SEB but couldn't see it.

06/07
Stiliyan Petrov........£6.5m
Didier Agathe........Signed
Chris Sutton........Free
John Carew Lyon........Swap
Ashley Young........£9.65m
Shaun Maloney........£1m
Nigel Reo-Coker........£7.5m
Total: £24.65m

07/08

Marlon Harewood........£4m
Zat Knight........£3.5m
Moustapha Salifou........Nominal
Wayne Routledge........£1.25m
Total: £8.75m

08/09

Curtis Davies........£8m
Steven Sidwell........£5m
Brad Friedel........£2m
Brad Guzan........£600K
Nicky Shorey........Signed
Luke Young........£5m
Carlos Cuellar........£7.8m
James Milner........Signed * think it was £12m
Emile Heskey........£3.5m
Total: £31.9m * + £12m

09/10
Stewart Downing........£12m
Fabian Delph........Signed
Habib Beye........Signed
Stephen Warnock........Signed
James Collins........£5m
Richard Dunne........£5m
Total: £22,000,000 + Delph, Beye and Warnock

During this time he clawed back £32.6 mill and since then the club have clawed back an extra £63 mill from the sales of Milner, Downing and Young.

All in all some cracking buys, a few dodgies (Davies and Cuellar in particular) and a bad sale (Cahill for 5 mill).

that's not as bad as i thought if i'm honest. Not great but a few good signings

[Bear]

Originally Posted by Tony_Montana1981

Good signings



Bad signings.

The others - meh

Collins has been good for Villa, Petrov has been solid if unspectacular

[jsdftm04]

Originally Posted by Bear

Collins has been good for Villa, Petrov has been solid if unspectacular

not too great value for money at the time but over the time they have been there it's not too bad.

Harewood and Davies were awful signings

[Coeus]

Swapping one that signs good players but cant win for another that signs shit players but can. Funny old game.

[SuperKev]

Originally Posted by Bear

Collins has been good for Villa, Petrov has been solid if unspectacular

I would have said that about them anarl

[Tony_Montana1981]

Originally Posted by Bear

Collins has been good for Villa, Petrov has been solid if unspectacular

Dont think either were good value for the money paid.